I feel like there was never a time in law school when a prof of mine looked an opinion, turned to us, and said "this is just an unconstitutional ruling, and everyone should have ignored it."
We have trained generations of lawyers to be overly deferential to courts. And courts have exploited that.
RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:73t3muu2pudsajp7a2fj3aly/post/3n2rzas4o622r
1 Boost
0 Likes
I know that will make a lot of law prof types uncomfortable, bc now "rule of law" stops being about procedural commitments to following certain actors and becomes about substantive decisions over what actually IS lawful.
But ... that's what the "rule of law" has always been.
Procedural views are no less steeped in substantive, normative commitments than explicitly substantive ones. Procedural views just hide the substantive piece a bit. But it's still inescapably there.
I’ve done it. In open court. And wasn’t so gentle with my words.
The path back from this is going to be unpleasant, and over-reaching courts have no one but themselves to blame for it.
But law schools need to get a lot more comfortable, quickly, with telling our students that courts can be unlawful too, and just bc it is in an op doesn't make it law.