🤖 First a ChatGPT-style knot. Now a ChatOn-style loop. An identity crisis with a recurring subscription.
🚨 A highly downloaded US Mac app deserves more scrutiny—not more borrowed credibility.
My new investigation covers Hira Amin’s “AI Chatbot・Ask AI Anything”, No. 13 in Apple’s US Top Free Mac chart when checked on 18 November.
Here is what the evidence shows:
🎭 Changing borrowed identities. The app’s archived icon closely imitates ChatGPT; its current artwork closely imitates ChatOn. Original images are compared side by side, alongside reviews describing ChatGPT purchase confusion.
🔗 A documented development connection to another Apple account. Signed files from Hira Amin’s and Hadiqa Bashir’s apps name the same developer, reproduce a matching custom warning and share internal code labels. This is stronger evidence than a similar name or icon. It establishes a development link, not the legal ownership of both accounts.
Hadiqa’s product is absent from the checked US, German and Irish Apple lookups, and the checked developer profile returns 404. Those results do not identify Apple’s enforcement decision or the reason for disappearance.
🔐 Another company sits in the prompt’s path. The app’s privacy policy says submitted content passes through the developer’s Firebase server before reaching OpenAI. The policy says the server does not retain it. Users should still know that this independent operator processes their requests; this is not a direct conversation with OpenAI’s official ChatGPT app.
💸 The listing offers $5.99 weekly and $49.99 yearly. Keeping the weekly subscription for a year has an estimated cost of $311.48.
Apple should review the misleading presentation, purchase-confusion complaints and connected development—not treat download-chart visibility as reassurance.
The report includes original branding comparisons, signed-file evidence, an account connection diagram, the data path and the relevant Apple review rules.
Read the investigation:
https://appscamdb.com/reports/chatbot-6753711999/
App:
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/ai-chatbot-ask-ai-anything/id6753711999?mt=12
Historical Hadiqa app (absent from checked Apple lookups):
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/id6752956793?mt=12
Apple developer accounts:
Hira Amin: https://apps.apple.com/us/developer/hira-amin/id1844599654
Hadiqa Bashir: https://apps.apple.com/us/developer/hadiqa-bashir/id1841912694
#Apple #AppStore #MacOS #AI #ChatGPT #ConsumerProtection #Privacy #scam #scammer #chaton #openai