Where do you think humanity would be today if its technology had been used for the common good, rather than to create the neo-feudalism that U.S. capitalism inevitably leads to?
This content is not available.
Where do you think humanity would be today if its technology had been used for the common good, rather than to create the neo-feudalism that U.S. capitalism inevitably leads to?
This content is not available.
Points at China
What makes you think that a different logic prevails in China? Don’t you think this system is so successful because it combines cutthroat capitalism with the authoritarian control mechanisms inherent in communism? Do you think technology is used in this way for the benefit of the people?
First, I need to state that I don’t agree with the implication that China is at all the answer to this question. But I have to say authoritarian control is not inherent to communism. There are lots of communes that aren’t authoritarian. Maybe some day we figure out how to scale communism while preserving real democracy and avoiding the mistakes of the past. But it’s not inherent in the design.
I think the problem here is China is also a reflection and response to those same global capitalist-imperialist forces.
It will offend some that have internalized a western chauvinistic and reactionary lens for history, but you can’t explain China’s history or present day without contextualizing the influence western(and eastern) capitalist imperialism had in shaping and constraining China wrt it’s development and how it thought about those questions.
Seriously. While I’m not a cheerleader for China by any stretch, I am still baffled by people’s naivety. The majority of the Western world has been undermining and sabotaging countries experimenting with socialism and communism for as long as they’ve existed. Every effort and been made to ensure that they fail and look bad doing it. From economic warfare and industrial sabotage to propaganda and coups. If a significant percentage of dissidents are bankrolled by foreign nations looking to destabilize your government, its hard to respond with more freedom and western powers abuse that fact. It should come as no surprise that the result is paranoia, secret police, cenorship, trade wars, and authoritarian tendencies. A huge factor in China’s success has been that most western powers were so intensely focused on undermining and sabotaging the Soviets. China was able to watch the cold war, learn, and progress to a degree without being the primary recipient of capitalist violence.
I wouldn’t call it “US specific” in particular. Euro-colonial-capitalism led in many ways directly to the formation of the USA, which had a lot of ulterior motives relating nothing to the stated aims of ‘throwing off tyranny,’ ’no taxation without representation’ and similar stuff.
And much of Euro-colonial-capitalism (powered by Renaissance tech in many ways) can trace its roots to much older kingdom and empire-building, which can trace themselves directly to the Neolithic and Agricultural Revolutions, 12Kyrs ago.
IMO you kind of have to rely on fantasy and sci-fi to imagine a picture of humanity that oddly didn’t behave like typical sapiens when it comes to such fantasy capitalism scenarios.
I was referring to U.S. capitalism, since it is responsible for the vast majority of problems today: If not in the personified form of organized crime, as represented in all its depravity by the current U.S. regime, then certainly through the profiteers of this system in other countries, who are undermining democracy in order to create the same inhumane conditions as in the U.S. - one example of this would be Friedrich Merz, the Chancellor of Germany.
Oh man, we’d all have personal jet-packs that ran on water and holiday homes on Venus. It would have been awesome.
I think it would have been a Star Trek-type thing, but water-powered jet packs and all that are actually an even nicer utopia.
I don’t think life would be radically different to today but we’d probably already have a base on the moon, clean energy production and much better mental health than what we have today.
Was never going to happen. Humans are animals.
An even worse place
Bad intentions may be bad
But good intentions destroy societies
Fully Automated Luxury Gay Space Communism
Our medical science would be so advanced that we’d be able to be treated for broken and lost teeth that re-growing them would be done in a few days. We would get over the stigma of religious resistance and be allowed to grow organs that’d be just as good as the ones we’re born with so transplants can be systematically easier.
We would artificially be immortal. We could still die in some ways, so we’re not purely immortal, but we’d be able to overcome so many obstacles for our health never before seen.
And healthcare would be affordable on top of it.
Yes, I think the profit-driven logic prevents innovation and compassion, especially in the medical field: Hardly any medical technology company conducts research on rare diseases, and no pharmaceutical company would ever forgo profits in order to heal people.
Instead, these billion-dollar behemoths buy up patents from startups that, as university spin-offs, received substantial public funding. These patents are sometimes not even used at all, as they were purchased solely to prevent them from interfering with profitable products - and it’s not even a matter of which approach is better: This is irrelevant to the leadership of these corporations, since they are concerned exclusively with profit.
You need to log in to see that page.
Coast-to-coast orgy.