The problem w raw numbers like this is it doesn’t account for diffs in contested-ness.
This was an issue in the WI gerrymander case. The Dems ran in every state leg district, but the GOP didn’t even run ppl in some cities.
So Dem‘s share of vote wasn’t a perfect measure of Dem’s share of the pop.
RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:5jxq665jzrekunbjdjgixupa/post/3n2jaew2nac2r
1 Boost
0 Likes
And over the years, we’ve seen ideology sorting along urban lines, with cities increasingly Dem.
So that creates a sort of “natural” gerrymander that isn’t the fault of maps, and further makes vote-share-to-seat-share harder to interpret.
The growing Democratic dominat...
I’m not saying there’s no gerrymander issue!
But, empirically, the share of Dem vote does not tell us the share of seats Dems should have if contestedness varies by urbanness (and thus Dem-ness).
Now, obv, some of the turnout diff is itself a product of gerrymandering—Dems HAD to run everywhere to overcome bad maps.
But there is also a “natural” gerrymander inherent to all land-based maps (as opposed to at-large): cities are always under-repped vs less dense places.