as someone with no special skills or ambitions, and who didn't go to an elite university, i can see the appeal of the "anti-elitist" right
the idea of "those ivory tower intellectuals are leading you astray" is powerful (and partially accurate) enough that even people on the left fall into that sort of thinking (consider how many people gave up on economics because a lot of mainstream economists one sees on TV express narrow-minded positions)
and nobody likes to realize that they as a person are probably never going to be influential because they're not part of the same circles as the elites (be it the movie industry, the military, their own workplace...)
but if the last few years have shown anything, it should be that perhaps the nerds who went to the top schools and graduated with honors are probably better skilled to run the economy or the armed forces or entire departments of government than some random person the head of government happens to know