New blogpost:
"Not All Men"
Sorry, a bit of a ranty one, in the context of recent/current news in the UK.
It does mention sexual assault, but the focus is on men.
Not All Men
Discussion
New blogpost:
"Not All Men"
Sorry, a bit of a ranty one, in the context of recent/current news in the UK.
It does mention sexual assault, but the focus is on men.
Not All Men
@neil v one comedian talking about doing something and platforming people who are already is @robinince
@neil Well said, Neil.
And that's an excellent Mash Report segment in the link.
I also flicked through the research behind the comments in the other related blog, and holy smokes, 95.1% of men surveyed admitted to using tactics from that list of absolutely repulsive behaviours? Yes, collectively, we have to do so so so much better.
@neil This. I think everywhere I or my wife have ever worked (public and private sector) has had creepy men who behaved badly, or worse towards junior women. Everybody knew, and the issues were raised, but the managers, many of them nice "liberal" people did NOTHING, except make excuses for the men. Lots of young women left and that was that. 🤮🤬 Men need to call out men. If some men are inclined to bad behaviour, at least fear of consequences should be a thing. That's on the rest of us.
@FaithfullJohn @neil
I once hired a creepy-looking guy to reach undergrads. He wasn’t very good, but he didn’t do or say anything bad. We were desperate and out of time so hired him.
We got numerous complaints from students that he was creeping them out. And he said stuff to us that was stupid or annoying. But no one had specific complaint, it was all vibe. Nothing more happened, no shoe dropped. Complaints were all vibes-based.
Did I do the wrong thing? I’m still not sure.
@ThreeSigma @FaithfullJohn I can't say that you did the "wrong" thing, on so limited facts.
But I would reflect on whether, if lots of people were "creeped out", that the situation demand some investigation and pro-activity, rather than just waiting for a specific type of incident or complaint.
@neil @ThreeSigma Yes. Not *everything* needs to be formally escalated to HR etc. Some men think it's funny/manly to show off *to other men* by saying sexually charged things to women. It's not, and sometimes all you need to do is make your disagreement plain.
The assumption that you share their views, or find this funny should be offensive to you as well as women. If more men did this, there would be a lot less threatening "banter" around, and create a much better environment for everybody.
@neil I fully respect your point about #notallmen In a well-meaning attempt to express hope, in my experience it is #notallenvironments My world is a million miles away from men with power. My line manager is a woman, the CEO of our organisation is a woman, the department heads that I work with are women. I was in a meeting today with senior representatives of several organisations, and it was 9 women and 6 men. My wife has a PhD, my mum has a PhD, I only have an MBA.😉
@neil I like this post more than another post that I recently read. Mostly because instead of relying on statistics for a population that might not fit, it clearly states "women have to assume *all* men until proven otherwise through action" and that realizing a man might not be put in a situation for that proof to ever come. It makes it very clear the power imbalance in men's favor and, as you said, the violations women have suffered as a result.
Just as you cannot change the shape of a ceramic pot after it has been fired, you cannot change the fundamental behaviour of a person beyond childhood.
The only realistic way to tackle this issue is at its source: upbringing.
@rq4c And that is of no use for those who are men now, so there is still a necessity for us to deal, even if imperfectly, with men.
Perhaps if we addressed the root causes, we might also find solutions for the now?
@rq4c Sure - as long as we are also tackling the "now", learning from how we might tackle it as part of parenting / upbringing could be valuable. I'm not necessarily convinced that that is the only source of opportunity, but it cannot hurt to consider it.
@neil one guy at work was ranting about this, "Not all men are rapey bastards!", and I had to point out that, actually, not all men are safe for women to be around, and in fact it is just about impossible to prove that a man is safe to be around - just because you haven't done something yet doesnt mean you won't in 5 minutes¹.
In many ways, its easier if men are known to be abusers - ive seen support networks spring up to keep certain men away from women - but its certainly more dangerous if a particular man is thought to be safe, if he suddenly turns out to be something else.
All we can do is lead by example, and call out any bad behaviour
¹And yes, im including myself in this - I know im not like that, but no woman can be sure of that.
@neil Thanks Neil. Good post and it is very helpful to see it from a man.
I think men need to call in other men at all levels from shutting down shitty jokes through to having a quiet word with someone who is making women uncomfortable. Be the man who says "I am happy to call other men in if you like" and be willing to share resources and encourage other men to be and behave better.
Where someone clearly continues with creepiness regardless of intervention; are they worth talking to?
@neil you make a point here that touches with my awful experience of sexual assault as a child. For a long time afterwards I did not trust any man.
Obviously, not that every man posed imminent danger to me, but I could no longer interpret how a man would look at me. Every time a man looked at me in the street, I wanted to fold myself up, so he couldn't see the parts of me that made me woman-ish.
It was not the fault of those men, but I could no longer process what might constitute danger.
@GoingDownWithSundial Yes. And how horrible :(
May I boost that, please?
@neil of course.
It's terrible how some shitty person can, in just a few minutes, change a person's sense of self so fundamentally that the effects last for years.
(Two different posts - that was from mine, whereas @fishidwardrobe was talking about a different post.)
@sijmen Fantastic, isn't it!
And have you heard Rachel Parris sing?
I've heard that comedians often have to work harder than men comedians, and wow I can believe that that is true - she sung on one (perhaps more) of the recordings of "I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue", and it was just *epic*.
YouTube
@neil This, although I have just muted someone for a long blog post saying that statistics show that it's literally every man literally offering violence to women, even gay men? OP looked male to me -- no pronouns in bio -- so I assume they were including themselves?
Lots of confused thinking about this, I think. Not your post, though.
I can't speak to a piece that I have not read, but if is around *fear* of violence / offering violence, then I could see the angle.
@neil wouldn't ask you to.
it seemed to me to be conflating trying to persuade women into sex with sexual violence. i'm not comfortable with the former, but (a) i really doubt that every man does that, and (b) in my mind it's very different from the latter.
it was all rather confusing.
[Same caveat about not having read the piece.]
I've definitely read some literature that equates sex with violence, and pornography with rape. So views of that nature would not be entirely surprising.
I can also see how one might readily argue that "pick up artistry", and other such revolting, predatory behaviour is a form of sexual assault.
https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/news/ex-kingsley-napley-director-suspended-for-inappropriate-behaviour/5128523.article
Ex-Kingsley Napley director suspended for inappropriate behaviour