Oh yes, the largest communities here are toxic shitholes. Politics, Memes, News, Comics, all are high contentious battlegrounds. Tbf the same is true and in fact far worse on Reddit, or was before the most heavy extremists were banned and now they are here instead of there anymore.
And if a new joiner came here and did not block as you did, they would have an extremely skewed perspective of this place. Numerically speaking though, it is your (and Blaze, and my) perspective that is different from the normal. Exception: PieFed.social bans all 3 of the tankie triad right away for new accounts, so that does significantly reduce that issue.
The history of TenForward was that the user Stamets had some drama with the !Risa@startrek.website mods and went off and started his own community, along with NegativeNull, ThePicardManeuver, and then Ummthatguy joined later, and then Stamets left and went off to make his own second Risa, !Risa@emmy.dbzer0.com. Anyway, if you look at the mod teams of the two TenForward communities that I mentioned, you will see that they are identical. So those two I would say are the most apt comparison - one is on Lemmy and the other on PieFed, but all other factors are the same.
Except one: TenForward on LW was the original community, and the PieFed one came along later, without much promotion from pretty much anyone that I’ve seen. There definitely is a strong effect whereby since the OG one is still present, and extremely highly active (one of the largest communities across the entire Threadiverse), that people stick with the OG one and have no need for the other. Especially when PieFed.World barely exists itself - see e.g. the paltry showing at piefed.world/topics, despite the multi-comnunity topic feed areas being one of the most popular features of the PieFed software platform.
There once was excitement that PieFed was going to overtake Lemmy. Now, even with v1.0 having been delayed for 18 months as you said, the excitement about PieFed is shrinking or already over. This here that exists now is pretty much what the Threadiverse will be for the next decade, as we continue to lose more people than we gain over time, and the software tools go into maintenance mode with a declining audience for their features offered.
In the short term, I don’t see this as particularly problematic,
Agreed - this is what must be, the only issue is that new joiners need to adjust to it, like communities don’t exist for specific games so much as just a gigantic “games” community, and at best perhaps an exceedingly generalized genre (but not finer-grained subgenres).
I see the flotilla as protecting against an authoritarian action by the .world admins
I was not trying to pass a moral judgement there, just stating it as almost a foregone conclusion that the Threadiverse is going to split. And then I added those details about who is going to cause it and why they said that they would. Also, the end result will be even fewer visitors to the Threadiverse, as even the upcoming tension that it might happen may already be affecting people’s recommendations as to what instances to join (regardless of whether or not it should happen or not, which I suppose mainly turns on whether the evidence was faked or not, which I admittedly haven’t bothered to examine as I see that point as irrelevant to the endpoint). Once again that increases the “complexity” required to be able to navigate this place.
Here we are free. This is no walled garden, or rather it is many gardens, or I prefer the analogy instead of free trader and pirate ships. The downside is that you leave behind “civilization” when you come here - there are no kings, not exactly, but there are fiefdoms, and you either need to learn how to self-host your own boat (which in today’s modern climate is hellish due to all the LLM scrapers ignoring all rules and traditions alike, presumably even targeting single-user instances), or learn how to navigate all of this complexity. i.e. there are responsibilities that come with this freedom.
None of which Reddit / X / Threads / Insta / Tiktok demands of them. So (most of them) will simply remain there.
User blocklists: I saw that they were added!:-) But not that they were incompatible:-(. Of all the petulance… :-|
Related to your personal blocking (me too ofc, as with most Lemmings): you tend to miss out on such gems as lemmy.ml/post/55085010/28894101 (link is to a comment but the entire post is illustrative as well), and also this post lemmy.ml/post/54724340?sort=Top - make sure to sort comments by Hot or Top and see especially (but not exclusively) the top one. Calls for literal murder tend to turn mainstream normies away. We are an extremist / tankie bar here, whether some of us block it out or not, numerically such posts remain and new joiners are extremely likely to stumble upon them. Especially if they pick Lemmy.ml as the flagship instance, which shows Local rather than All posts to a guest viewing without an account.
Every single person that I have mentioned the Lemmy platform to has outright chided me for telling them about it. We block, but new joiners don’t know how yet, and to them, the above pair of posts mostly exemplifies what this place is. An extremist place, highly opinionated, and not terribly welcoming to mainstream folk, who tend to be centrist, religious, and non-technical, unlike the prevailing trends here.