I'm planning to do this in mid-december. It does not need to be a holiday film.
Next year, we're going to screen Dracula (English, Spanish) and Dracula in Istanbul, Frankenstein, The Public Enemy, Little Ceaser, The Bat Whispers, Filibus The Mysterious Air Pirate, Orochi (the serpent aka outlaw), the romance of the western chamber (aka way down west, aka the bandit and the rose), and (assuming we get our dub finished in time) either Tourist Omer in Star Trek or Lionman (aka the sword and the claw.)
For this first screening, I am considering: Santa conquers the martians, manos the hands of fate, night of the living dead, charade, or possibly His Girl Friday.
I am open to further suggestion! I'd love for it to be a more recent movie, something from a fediversian or an independent creative team, but if that's where we go I'll need help making contact.