Posted in
Fediverse
Everyone can post a case via normal Fedi posts to the court and the elected judges give a verdict via majority vote. Once a case has a verdict, all instances should immediately apply the decided action against the offending content / account.
My immediate thought reading this was, how does that work across jurisdictions? Is the idea that every jurisdiction runs its own instance of this software? Something illegal in one jurisdiction might not be in another.
There's also the question of representation. Does every (lemmy/mbin/piefed) instance get the same representation? If there's proportional representation, that just promotes centralization of the fediverse. If there's not, you can just set up new instances to manipulate the vote.
And the task of the court is to defend universal rules all following instances agree on.
Sure, but are there checks and balances which ensure that?