An Air Force Major Is Being Held in Solitary Confinement for Criticizing Trump on CNN
cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/94658
An Air Force Major Is Being Held in Solitary Confinement for Criticizing Trump on CNN
cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/94658
What’s even more messed up is that it isn’t. It’s a crime for commissioned officers to speak negatively of the President or basically any other executive official.
Oh no, I know that, sorry. I meant the way he’s being punished before a trial has been conducted.
Also, shockingly, not illegal. US military justice is messed up.
But it isn’t legal though.
He can be court martialed. He can see criminal charges.
They skipped straight to torture.
I agree, but it’s unfortunately within the scope of the law. They will argue the confinement was necessary to prevent ongoing misconduct. It’s blatant extrajudicial punishment, but our system is very lenient for these types of things in the State’s favor.
You keep saying these things like you’re a lawyer? The point of the article is that it’s NOT in the scope of the law to do what they’re doing…
Can you please provide any sources?
Unless one of us is a military lawyer, all of our opinions hold equal weight.
Yes. So we should provide sources lest we propagate non-sense.
I’ve got a separate set of comments on this post where I do that. Because I’m trying to understand why this case has differed from my own experience with these issues while I was in the military.
UCMJ article 13. This is arguably within those very lenient lines. Can be held for up to 120 days before trial. Again, it’s legal, and that’s the problem. The confinement is punitive and it is more than is necessary. It should be illegal. Unfortunately, the interpretation of the law is up to those that benefit from its loosest interpretation. They’ll argue that this confinement is necessary because they need to prevent additional harm (the speech the officer used). It’s BS, but as long as those enforcing the law accept that lame excuse, it’s legal.
Major Watson said, “What matters far more than who I am is what I have to say and the price I’m willing to pay to say it.”
I think we should understand that price. He is charged with a violation of UCMJ Article 88: Contempt toward officials. It specifically prohibits commissioned officers from using contemptuous language about the president. He also faces charges under Articles 92 and 133, which carry additional potential penalties.
If convicted of all counts and he receives the maximum penalties, he faces 15 years in prison, forfeiture of pay, and dismissal from service. A dismissal would cost him his military retirement after 17 years of service and would jeopardize his veterans’ benefits. Perhaps a pardon by the next president or an appeals process could eventually restore some of that, but otherwise, that man’s entire career could be over with nothing to show for it except the respect of those who know, and the honor of having stood up to do the right thing — both of which have egregiously bad financials.
Yeah, I’ll edit my comment. I meant illegal to help him in solitary, which is the focus of the article. Sorry for wasting your time, it is helpful information for others though!
Yup, that’s a crime for US military officers. UCMJ 88
Land of the free. The home of free speech. The bastion of democracy…
Those fighting for freedom sacrifice many of the freedoms we enjoy.

But we’re talking about the United States military, though.
So is murdering children.
Spend a day in solitary confinement and then see if you still feel that way. Matter of fact, you could just sit on your couch doing literally nothing for 5 hours and see how that goes. It’s still not as bad, and I bet you’d hate it.
Have you read the article?
Watson has been convicted of no crime. Military law says a service member awaiting trial cannot be punished, and confinement may not be any more rigorous than the circumstances require.
He has been charged, he is being held pretrial. Pretty normal criminal trial, not sure how the military handles bail. It’s the conditions, solitary for a poor reason, that I see is the issue. He definitely broke military law, but he is being punished harshly to make a point to the rest of us.
Doesn’t make it moral or right.
Legal does not equal moral, ethical, or correct.
Legal means some jackass somewhere decided it was ok.
That’s it.
Technically it just means some jackass somewhere didn’t decide it wasn’t ok.
that’s a crime for US military officers
Do we usually torture people over committing a crime?
In America, YES WE ABSOLUTELY DO. Solitary confinement is considered torture and yet is regularly used not only on our prison populations (for even those serving time for minor non-violent offenses) but also on our children in juvenile detention. Nevermind that prisoners are subjected sexual violence, medical neglect, live in dangerous/unsafe conditions, are used as forced labor (and punished if they refuse) - seriously I could go on. We should be focused on rehabilitation but instead have gone all in on punative and psychological torment and no one notices or cares because “they’re criminals.”
Is it wrong, yes. It’s it dictator shit, yes. Is it illegal, surprisingly no. Commissioned officers can’t say things like that in public.
“illegal” matters not when it’s dictator shit.
Truth. Basically everything the Nazis did was legal under Nazi law, fuck that. Legality only matters when the system is just.
Nuremberg Trials seem to have been a waste huh?
Good thing legal and moral/ethical are not at all the same.
Commissioned officers can’t say things like that in public
um ok so they get fired, not tortured… you ok with that?
This is America!
Huh, now here is how an adult handles the situation:
I think Major Jason Watson deserves more attention than he’s been getting over this. Solitary confinement isn’t just cruel and unusual punishment. It’s torture.
Maybe No King’s can refresh his attention for the next protest.
Trump acting like a baby yet again. Solitary confinement is very cruel and unusual. I read that free speech is treated differently in the military, but Jason Watson here did not deserve this; Watson didn’t deserve punishment at all. The right to free speech is getting abused by the Trump admin for sure.
Babies don’t put people in solitary. Trump is acting like a despot.
“Tyrant” also works.
From the administration that whines like a rusty hinge about “lawfare”.
This is illegal, and yet, his attorneys can’t do anything to get him out?
And his military unit isn’t doing anything to help?
This whole thing stinks. I hate these people