The age of forums was when the internet peaked.
Another hearsay, but a big problem were trolls and spammers who were bombing many communities.
@topher1kenobe @jackdaniel @futtta Outrageous trolls and spammers got banned as long as there was a healthy moderator team.
What killed a forum were long term members who interacted in the limits of acceptable behavior who wouldn't get expelled. They soured the community for many people. Then people would leave and only these borderline trolls would remain.
Looking back, users being able to block other users was the solution. Some forum software lacked them. Some had them, but people were hesitant to use them at first
@hugoestr @topher1kenobe @futtta
imo forums were coopted and extinguished by likes of facebook and reddit.
note that gp discussion was about usenet.