Funnily enough this is also how I feel about academics who seem unable to critique ideas & actions and hedge endlessly... as if stating a strong opinion clearly is anything but healthy discourse. Why are we academics otherwise? Take a stand against genocide or AI or something. Dare to do your job.
RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:llf62mn5l6x42eaegjeg5yd5/post/3n2tvgi4d5s2a
Also reminder...
Stop saying AI might be useful for other fields as if usefulness blesses use and creates ethicality on its own. And as if you know what other fields need or really have done — don't make AI hydraulic: if you know it's no good, don't push it onto your neighbours so save yourself.
If you're not an avowed utilitarian, which many who do push AI violently are, don't say it might do things (be useful) and that therefore it may be beneficial. That logical frame isn't for you so don't push it onto cancer and protein research. It's just pure propaganda.
I know who with big platforms have said this and I'm glad when they stop and reconsider. So that's great. I'm pleased they listen. But it's still so widespread we need to keep saying it's not a good way to engage.
For more on this see this thread:
RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:vsyj5jtayxcq5dw5mtja4xtb/post/3mxvgx7hr622m
Sometimes we need to confront what systems we're in and the deep power as academics we do hold. Otherwise not only do we lose our own individual humanity, but we risk the entirety of our collective millennia long project through being university employees who have no backbone.