In the book "1984", INGSOC claims the equation "2 + 2 = 5" is true. What is happening here, and can we rationalize it with group theory? I posit a group with group operation f(x,y) = x + y + 1. [In layman's terms, we redefine + to add the operands normally and then add an additional one.] Analyzing this group, we quickly find -1 to be the identity element, and conclude it is isomorphic to ℤ via the transformation f(x) = x+1, such that "2 + 2 = 5" in the INGSOC group equivalent to 3 + 3 = 6 in ℤ.
You do have to admit, 3 + 3 = 6 is in fact a true statement
@mcc something something, hyperbolic coordinate plane, something something, non-Euclidean space, something something, multidimensional reality.
Perfidious Abelian
@mcc well you can just use the same multiplication as in Z, which after isomorphism will turn into m_ingsoc(x,y) = a_z(a_z(m_z(x,y)), x), y).
For example, for multiplication of 2 and 2 we obtain 8.
Considering that a_z(x, y) = a_ingsoc(a_ingsoc(x, y), -2), we obtain m_ingsoc(x,y) = a_ingsoc(a_ingsoc(a_ingsoc(a_ingsoc(m_z(x,y)), x), -2), y), -2), which means that in ingsoc terms, x*y = m_z(x, y) + x + y - 3. E.g. in ingsoc, 2*2 = 4 + 2 + 2 - 3 = 8. Or 4*5 = 20 + 4 + 5 - 3 = 29.
And of course every property Z has, ingsoc also had because they're isomorphic.
Questions I have not explored, because the above analysis was done in my head while waiting for a cheeseburger, and then the cheeseburger arrived:
- Is the INGSOC group abelian? (Strongly suspect yes.)
- Can a "multiplication" operation be found which transforms the INGSOC group into a ring or field? (Suspect yes, and propose the candidate f(x,y) = x*y+y, which I have not tested)