Is it a controversial take if I say I never liked the obsessive focus on ray tracing as a technology? Like I don't hate it, I think it's pretty cool, but seeing it as the "future of gaming" always felt like a giant smoke sell to me.
I mean it's pretty noticeable now with hardware shortages and prices in crazy numbers, but I've always followed a philosophy of "I want my game to run in the most devices as possible", and going for "next gen graphics" was completely against that goal.
I think it's something about growing up with shitty hardware and knowing how it feels to not be able to play most stuff.
I want to end generational low-end hardware trauma lol.
@NullTheFool it's also really expensive to make games of that detail, and I think we've hit a ceiling on how expensive games can be
@NullTheFool I think there’s room for it all. There are some games that use it to great effect, e.g. CONTROL, and I think Cyberpunk 2077 (though I haven’t played it through).
Nothing wrong with using new hardware to push gaming tech forward IMO. It’s exciting! Doesn’t mean all games should do it though.
@NullTheFool Studied games, made games, made 3D models that could possibly "benefit" from raytracing, and yet raytracing is just not that fascinating to me.
Hyper-realism is just one genre of art. The only criteria I've ever been meaningfully evaluated upon when making games has been whether they're fun or not. I don't need raytracing in a tetris clone for it to be fun.
One of my instructors insisted he'd never play a game if it had primarily pixel art graphics. If it's any surprise, it wasn't his only terrible take >.>
@crocodisle omg you just reminded me of that epidemic of "I remake X game but with ray tracing" that happened some years ago, holy shit.
Also, yeah with that take I expect that teacher to have many more.
@NullTheFool I HATE the "high quality" graphics it's one of the reasons I hate FF7 Remake just from the trailers. Give me something more stylized and FUN like Dobbel Dungeon or the classic retro graphics.
@NullTheFool@mastodon.gamedev.place
yeah, ray tracing has always seemed like the "easy" and boring solution to me
I find non-raytrayced solutions to shadows and lights much more interesting from a technical perspective 😁
@jcm "But what about reflections and mirrors?"
My siblings in 3D, we can already replicate that realistically without a 2k+ GPU as a requirement.
@NullTheFool@mastodon.gamedev.place
yeah, exactly 😁
gotta put in some creativity and cool solutions rather than just throwing GPU compute at the problem 😁
@jcm If only we could go back to those times... OH WAIT, WE CAN.
@NullTheFool but we need ray tracing to "democratize game development"!
@nonbinarycoder One day I gotta rant about the use of "democratize x", but I have to phrase it correctly to avoid the gatekeeper allegations lol
@NullTheFool Ray Tracing software first came out in 1967, so... if it's the future of gaming...
@NullTheFool I think in practice it's been a net-positive but...
It was really weird for it to be a dedicated feature instead of just addressing whatever issues there were with doing it in compute shaders. It makes way too many assumptions about a very specific way of doing things being the best.
It's also slow, and the solutions to that have mostly been of the "temporal artifacts are totally fine!" variety.
This is just me extrapolating my dislike for the overall photorealism obsession in the game dev industry, so feel free to correct me if you think I'm missing something