How do you read a comic book?
This content is not available.
How do you read a comic book?
This content is not available.
I have aphantasia and it really doesn’t apply to reading comic books, where the images are right there in front of your eyeballs.
What you might have in addition to aphantasia is a strong preferences for text over images–the reason I end up reading subtitles in English if they are on, even though English is my native language.
I think what ended up happening for me is that I would read a comic book almost without glancing at the images at first, but on re-reading, the more I already knew what the text was, the more I looked at the images. You could try that.
Or you could do it on a per-page basis–read the text first, then look at the images before flipping to the next page.
doesn’t apply to reading comic books
What do you mean. I’m sure some people are using their mind’s eye to “play” the comic book images in their head.
What you might have in addition to aphantasia is a strong preferences for text over images
I don’t like subtitles, I would turn them off when possible. They are distracting when not needed but I don’t think because my brain wants to read them but because they magically appear on the screen to catch your eye’s attention.
I would read a comic book almost without glancing at the images at first, but on re-reading, the more I already knew what the text was, the more I looked at the images
That is a great tip! Like I feel like there is a disconnect to how much I can enjoy both at the same time and it just messes up pacing and everything.
Ideally I’d enjoy reading a comic like watching an anime. Read subtitles and follow the story with the moving frame pictures. I mean the only difference is that an anime has a lot more frames so missing a couple doesn’t matter. But it forces the images on you at a steady pace.
I’m going to try it again with both those in mind
Why would you “play” the comic books images in your head when you can just look at them? That’s the whole point of comic books!
With aphantasia, I only skim text descriptions if not skip them entirely. I can read all the words I want, my mind’s eye is not going to sketch an image for me.
But a comic book has the images right there for me to look at, so I don’t feel like aphantasia inhibits my enjoymet of comic books at all the same way it does for text fiction.
And I imagine non-aphantasiacs are also reading comic books because they enjoy looking at the pictures, else they would be reading regular books where their mind can provide them richer imagery.
I think reading comic books is “better” than watching subtitled anime because rewinding is so absolutely precise, instaneous, and painless… you just look at exactly the frame you want to review and it’s there, with accompanying text.
Anyway, have fun! I started reading comics in high school and I did get noticeably better at it. It’s a skill, like anything else.
I don’t think you’re looking at it from the perspective of someone with near hyperphantasia.
Can they come up with the image of Batman in their head from just words? Maybe with an extremely detailed description. But one simple panel gives them 1000+ words. They can take it and run with it.
I don’t know how good they can do it but if I could make images and read comics I’m definitely going to add as many panels my mind allows.
Like it has to be a completely different experience
And I imagine non-aphantasiacs are also reading comic books because they enjoy looking at the pictures, else they would be reading regular books where their mind can provide them richer imagery.
This goes back to the whole batman thing. Non-aphants can read comic books and their mind can provide them richer imagery. It’s not one or the other. Some might prefer starting from scratch, others might like the comic starting points.
Like the whole idea of rembering a comic is different for us. I’m sure there are people out there that could play all the panels of their favorite comic in their minds. That is wild to think about.
As someone with Aphantasia and SDAM this doesn’t look like you want a rational answer. We can’t do that shit, there’s no way around it.
I can still read comics, draw, read regular books, write, etc. You need to learn to accept it. Yes our experience may be is lesser, but comparison is a joy thief. Woe is me gets old really quickly.
I don’t struggle to look at the pictures in a comic book or manga so I don’t know about that, seems like something else to me. Not to invalidate I just don’t think it’s to do with aphantasia.
Upvoted though because I get the frustration.
Cover to cover. Repeat.
I say: get lost into it. If you think that the part that you like the best is the written word, go for that. Read it through. Leave it for a bit. Then go back to it and try to look for other things. How does a phrase change when it’s joined by an image? what does a font convey? Why is the page layout thought that way? Is there some pattern? In no time, you’ll find yourself looking at pages for a long amount of time. That’s how you know.
“Get lost into it”
Is a strange concept for someone with aphantasia.
When I read a traditional book I do not get a “head movie”
I’ve personally never got “lost into a book” before and I have read quite a lot of good ones.
When I read it is like I am creating an audiobook for myself to listen to. I subvocalize everything pretty much.
Hmm thinking about it now maybe I’d like comics with more thought bubbles than dialog bubbles. If that is even a thing.
many panels don’t even have words and are action scenes. its sorta like how do you watch a movie.\? do you listen and then think. don’t forget to admire the visuals?
I’d say it’s similar to watch a subtitled movie in another language.
I personally cannot read subtitles and watch everything else on the screen at the same time.
So I read subtitles and admire what I can about the visuals. The visuals are like panels in a comic, just more so missing one frame isn’t like missing a whole panel.
If the show was designed around subtitles or with subtitles in mind then during heavy reading parts less visual stuff would be going on that is needed for information to progress the story.
I can get lost in a movie. Just sit there, not really think, and enjoy it.
For example: Friend put on Welcome to Derry last night. I had no idea what to expect. Just sat, watched, and enjoyed. Like sometimes I’ll make predictions and stuff of what I think might happen or learn something about how it relates to something earlier. Think like that. But I am not trying to process the movie like I would be doing with a comic.
If I could sit down and just “soak” up knowledge like watching a movie with a comic I’d enjoy it.
I cannot do that for a comic books
well so there is nothing to miss with the comic. you take what you read in the context of the panel and the previous panels since something from the past may be referenced. Just a word of warnning about subtitles and age. I have been near sighted my whole life but in old age I am both near and far. However I also don’t hear as well. So I watch shows with subtitles because sometimes I cannot tell what was said. Luckily the subtitles tend to lag the spoken word.
If I have to deal with subtitles then it’s fine.
For example my brother’s wife’s first language isn’t English. So when I go over there to watch a show the subtitles are always on. Watching a show you’ve seen before and can almost quote with subtitles is what really irks me. If I needed the subtitles, then I accept them.
But a character beaming the information into my brain for it to automatically process is always going to be better than me having to read words at the bottom of the screen and process them
Have you tried getting headphones for your TV?
My fiance hates subtitles more than I do and she is closer to hyperphantasia. I’m sure we will both be sitting in headphones in our old ages.
Since dialog is out of mainly the front center speaker, I’m surprised they don’t make like a dialog talk box where you could put just that center speaker closer to you. Guess it wouldn’t work on everything and mainly just movies. You can always turn that speaker up in relation to the others. Sound engineering is wild
I read the words and take in the pictures almost passively. Maybe on a later reading I might take it slower and pore over the artwork.
Is it similar to watching a movie?
Interesting. I feel like I over analyze each panel to keep myself from “flowing”
Like I am going to take your tip as just press forward. That’s kind of what the other tips were, focus on what you can but you can always come back a second time.
I find myself just trying to get information out of the panels and thinking to myself "don't forget to admire the images"
It might not be the aphantasia at work here. I'm basically like this and while I do struggle with visualization I don't have straight up aphantasia. In any case my impression is that this isn't something you can "fix," but also you should probably try reading Hinamatsuri. It's the only comic (well manga but same difference) I've enjoyed until the end so it might click with you too. I'm really not sure why, but it could be that being a comedy there's more of a focus on character interactions than pretty images. If you do decide to give it a go, I recommend watching at least one episode of the anime (I'd recommend watching all of it but you said you don't like subtitles) so you can imagine how the characters sound. In any case if you're like me there's probably no tip or trick that'll make you enjoy comics as a medium. Sorry but there is only doom.
I’ll check it out! Thanks for the recommendation.
I watch some anime with my brother sometimes and if the subtitles are needed then I deal with it for the story. We watched My Hero Academia last.
so you can imagine how the characters sound
I narrate when I read and I don’t really do character voices in my head. Maybe that would help when reading comics if I tried to do that. That is a good point.
if you notice yourself skimming for the words, try one with no words at all for a bit. the arrival by shaun tan is a whole graphic novel without text, so the pictures are the only way through and there’s nothing to skim.
Paper versions. Left 2 right, Front 2 back