This Public Notice piece warns that Trump is turning everyone into conspiracy theorists, unfortunately, the irony is that it falls into the same trap itself. I want to examine why that happens, even with the best intentions. 🧵
RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:ebovc3hnxjadg5cuul6geibu/post/3n2t6ofkqcs22
But there's a distinction that needs to be made. Distrusting a government with a record of lying isn't conspiracism, it's a reasonable reading of their past record. The problem starts when distrust becomes a conclusion you hold before looking at the evidence, and nothing can shift it.
Healthy scepticism says "I don't believe you, show me the evidence." Disordered doubt says "I don't believe you, and whatever you show me won't change my mind." The first can be corrected and the second can't. How much someone distrusts matters far less than whether their conclusions can still move.
In what I call disordered formations, where conclusions shape what evidence is acceptable, what I call "disordered doubt" is used to reject information that challenges those conclusions. It's not unique to any formation, be they flat earthers, anti-vaxxers, or Syrian chemical weapon denialists.
Plenty of good investigations begin with a hunch or a suspicious motive. Functional inquiry tests the hunch and drops it if the evidence doesn't hold. In the disordered version the hunch becomes the answer, and evidence is recruited or denied to fit.
Now look at the article's advice. Rather than searching for official explanations, it says, ask why. Does this benefit Trump financially? Feed his ego? What kickbacks are involved? Those are fair questions. The problem is the advice stops there, with no step for testing the answers.
Then its main example, the FAA nationwide ground stop on 13 November. The piece points to new AI software (SMART) going live days earlier as the "natural culprit", and notes the company behind it donated to Sean Duffy's son-in-law's congressional campaign.
Other reports points elsewhere, the FAA traced the data flood to a radio site in Arkansas, where contractor L3Harris had just installed a new router, and a radar site in Texas. Why it happened is still unclear. The FAA says SMART doesn't feed into air traffic control at all.
The donation does deserves scrutiny, but it's a story about possible corruption, not evidence about what caused the outage. Put side by side, one starts to stand in for the other. Timing plus motive equals cause is how a lot of conspiracy theories get built.
When people don't trust the official answer, they fill the gap themselves. They take true but unrelated facts and link them into a story that fits what they already believe about the people involved, and that works the same way whatever your politics.
The official story did shift in the first few days, so some suspicion was fair, but by the time the piece ran, the router evidence was public, and the piece doesn't engage with it. That's how the gap gets filled, here by a writer genuinely trying to warn readers about it.
And I should be clear, that doesn't make the author a conspiracy theorist. Floating a poorly supported explanation isn't the same as holding a belief nothing can shift. But it is the first step on that path, and the piece shows how easily even careful, well-meaning people take it.
The piece also says you could generally trust the US government until 2017. Plenty of people would point to Iraq and WMD. Distrust didn't start with Trump, and many of today's conspiracy communities are made of people who share an experience of being lied to.
Both start from a real betrayal and both turn it into a rule that decides new cases in advance. In Syria, that rule led people to deny well-documented chemical attacks. A bad record is a good reason to check carefully, but it isn't a substitute for checking.
The bigger gap is that it treats lies as the whole problem, but I'd argue the deeper problem is when facts are established and nothing happens. When wrongdoing is exposed without consequences, people learn that power decides outcomes, not evidence.
And where people see the bodies meant to hold power to account as captured, they conclude they can't expect trustworthy explanations from the institutions that should be providing them. So where there's a real record behind that view, it isn't paranoia.
So even when officials give the right explanation, it arrives to the public as already discredited. If the people giving it are assumed to have been captured, a true answer lands with the public no better than a false one. That's the real cost of capture, true answers stop working too.
The way out isn't to trust the source, or to assume it's lying, it's to test the claim. This has happened before: in 2009 a contractor misconfigured a router during an earlier fibre upgrade, hitting 129 facilities. That's evidence beyond officials' word, the AI theory has nothing like it.
Sure, you can ask the US government to "show you the evidence," but based on past performance, will questions like that not be ignored, routinely? So for a government that routinely lies and routinely refuses requests for evidence, isn't the distinction you make here of little to no practical value?
As the article states, when a government lies constantly, or gives a different explanation every few days, people stop waiting for official answers and try to work things out for themselves. That's a natural response, especially into today's information environment.