do people who advocate running your own mail server know how easy it is to get your entire domain blacklisted for spam due to some misconfiguration?
@eniko I’m running my own mail server for over two decades and I would NEVER recommend anyone to do this! It’s a pain, especially (as with everything email) sending to fucking Gmail.
@darkdust @eniko Also been running my own email for 20+ years, I've never had issues with gmail, at least you can just get yourself unflagged from them if they have you flagged so long as you have everything set up correctly, hotmail however I swear blocks you every other week, and not just people like me that run their own email, apparently they block corporate domains on big email providers regularly as well, i think their end-goal is to just block everyone.
@eniko I self host, but don't advocate. There are enough gotchas/pain points to exceed the length of a toot 🫠
@eniko nope. they don’t.
@eniko it’s even easy to fuck things up when someone else is hosting (in the dns).
I've run my own server in the past, and run one now for some friends' webpages that I host. I know how much fun it is, so was really surprised to see all the, "Just self-host, lol" comments popping up on here.
I was wondering if something had changed? Was I missing some new "de-suck self-hosting" app or configuration?
No, people are just giving bad advice. :-P
@eniko after reading the replies I'm considering self-hosting, thanks!
@AnachronistJohn fortunately i have never been interested in self hosting but i know just enough about email that i know its dangerous
@eniko in my experience, running your own mail server is a great way to always end up caught in gmail's spam filter :/
@eniko That's why I proxy everything through the mail servers of my DNS provider :)
Working great since 2012. That thin veneer of Big Corpo does help, but it doesn't need to go any deeper than that.
@eniko I've been self hosting email for the last 25 years and it is so easy to get on a ban list.
FWIW the biggest spam I get are from Gmail accounts 🤷.
I don't really recommend self hosting unless you are willing to put up with the time sink to fix things when they break.
In my case, I was a sys/network admin a few years before becoming a developer, so I know what to expect.
That being said, it is incredibly rewarding when your email is up and there is a global Microsoft outage
@eniko It is hard, and some database actually scam people into paying to be unlisted. Does that mean we should not claim our right to have our own mail server though ?
@mehdi_benadel feel free if you want to but given how vital functioning email is I don't think telling people it's a good idea is a good idea
@eniko
I personally would not push people to do it without telling them how hard it can be. But I still don't understand how a 50 years old technology is still so hard to use and gatekeeped so much by corporations. We can do better.
@mehdi_benadel I mean isn't it harder than ever because of how corporate it is now?
@eniko Even after setting up DMARC and putting up with the horribly convoluted postifix and dovecot I was still having delivery issues with gmail so I just gave up