It's one thing that nowadays about 99% of retro releases seem to be done with generative AI tools; I don't find it particularly hard to tune out the noise. However, what's truly annoying is that many people just assume the same of the remaining 1% anyway. I just hope there will still be a functional scene left by the time we figure out where the chips fall...
1 Boost
0 Likes
@allanon Obvious cases aside, I'm not sure where the red line is. I'd say you're in dangerous territory when you're starting to outsource creative decisions to your tools instead of only automating well-defined tasks.
How would you feel though if we could achieve the same results as today, but without using everyone's work as the training data? If we had an analogue of AlphaZero for art, for instance. I expect we'd probably still be suffering the same harms.
@cobbpg
Are you a painter if you describe what you want painted to someone else, who then paints it for you?
For me, the line was crossed from the very beginning—it is not right to use tools trained at the expense of actual artists, coders, authors, and musicians.
Today, it all seems normal because it’s convenient for those who are lazy.
The "retro" scene is increasingly becoming a landscape of soulless, personality-free ports.
YT is the same GenAI mess...
We must resist at all costs!