Tankies keep insisting it's the best thing since sliced bread despite not existing anymore for over 30 years

At this stage, loving and pretending the Soviet Union is successful and still functional is necrophilia.
Tankies keep insisting it's the best thing since sliced bread despite not existing anymore for over 30 years

At this stage, loving and pretending the Soviet Union is successful and still functional is necrophilia.
Please give a verbose explanation.
All tankies know that the USSR failed. You’ll be hard pressed to find one that thinks otherwise. The Bolshevik revolution was successful in a specific objective: a movement for communism overthrew the government of an empire. The USSR was successful in multiple objectives, like defeating the Nazis, sacking Berlin, launching the first satellite, landing the first probe on another planet, landing the first probe on the moon, increasing life expectancy, increasing literacy, increasing nutrition, etc etc etc.
These are things that are historically uncontestable facts. What is presented in this comic is a strawman that nobody believes, least of all tankies.
All tankies know that the USSR failed. You’ll be hard pressed to find one that thinks otherwise.
But do they all agree on the cause?
I doubt it? I think at this point, most of them would agree with the prevailing analysis that the most mechanical cause for its failure was the leadership of Kruschev and his collaborators implementing reforms to create a wealth accumulation mechanism for the political elite. But how that came to pass I think is still not fully understood. If we understand Kruschev to be the beginning of the end, that means that Stalin failed to protect the revolution from internal revisionists. So essentially Stalin was paranoid that “the wrong people” were vying for power and he was right, and he purged so many people from politics, and still immediately after he died those exact people rose to the top. So Stalin failed in this responsibility, but if Stalin’s extreme behavior was actually founded in some form of real perception he had, then that means the whole system was shot through with people looking to undermine the revolution for self-enrichment for many years…
Mao and the CPC attempted to explain this as a problem with the culture of the people and thus attempted the cultural revolution as a solution. However, the CPC’s own analysis years later is that the cultural revolution was a mistake.
The Chinese did identify one mission critical component of revolution: self-critique. The Soviet project was not successful in cutlivating and incorporating criticism of the revolution. The Chinese identified that as a critical component of a revolutionary project and self-critique has become a structured, inculturated, and disciplined part of the CPC.
Is that enough? We’ll see. Remember that tankies see communist revolutions as experiments in governance, and that each project uncovers new learnings, new complexities, new mistakes, and new solutions and at least half the job is trying to determine which of those things are specific to that time and place and people and which can be abstracted into lessons for improving future revolutionary projects
Stalin was a murderous asshole and Marx would have hated him. I find you ponderings pretty distasteful in the context of actual socialist principles.
Experiments in killing massive amounts of people and still waiting on the first true socialist country let alone a stateless communist one. I wonder how many more mass executions/genocides…err expirements it is going take to get it “right”.
Hopefully you don’t buy into this kind of garbage and are just critiquing it for everyone’s benefit.
I spend more time on Lemmy than I should and these tankie people absolutely exist, but I don’t see them often at all. People who reflexively defend the West are much more common, along with their single-digit arguments.
The USSR collapsed. The USSR was communist. Therefore communism always fails.
The first time I was exposed to this idea was by my 3rd grade teacher and 90+% of Americans hold this ‘reasoning’ as an article of faith. The Soviet Union and China are just big-bads and the West is so much better about human rights. (So long as we’re just talking about the 20th century, and the Holocaust and both world wars somehow don’t count)
So I take it you haven’t wandered onto .ml much.
Also, .world only federates with one of the Tankie Triad. Try a different instance that federates with all three, and you’ll see a different picture for sure.
Saying communism failed because USSR failed - Dumb
Saying communism failed because it failed in every major country and never obtained the most important socialist objectives let alone a stateless society - Priceless
Also, anyone who thinks the US ever supported human rights is clearly incapable of reading history beyond US propaganda.
The people of Chillicothe, MO would like to have a word!
Yeah, so that’s what we call a strawman