I’m very excited to share our paper that just appeared in JTB! @petinozappala.bsky.social@bsky.brid.gy, Susanne Ressl, and I address the advancement of biological thinking by using levels of organization in neuroscience as a case study #HPS #hpbio #philsci #Neuroscience #DevBio #evosky
sciencedirect.com/science/articl...
In addition to highlighting gaps in knowledge and guiding experimentation, we also show how concepts like levels generate (ontological, epistemic, methodological, rhetorical) commitments that become entrenched, modified, or replaced over time.
We draw on contemporary and recent historical examples from neurobiology, including postulating new levels (like microcircuits and neuronal populations) and the development and testing of cryo-electron microscopy, where the evolution of commitments around the levels concept are front and center.
With this we also show how science proceeds by relying on these commitments and iteratively reshaping them. Regarding levels, this is expressed in our use of well-established notions such as “cell” or “organism”, but also less stereotypical ones, such as “microcircuits”, and their change over time.
While drawing on neurobiology, our message is intended for experimental biologists of all stripes. We note that the level concept’s basic expressions find currency in the experimental investigation of biological form, and that organization in biology is studied as a product and process.
In this article we explore how concepts are employed to aid scientific reasoning, focusing specifically on the levels concept as a case study. This concept is used in descriptive roles, guiding roles, and hybrid roles when experimentally engaging biological systems.