Who's (ironically or unironically) your favorite Mary Sue/Gary Stu character of all time and why?
This. I know it’s a not-entirely inaccurate joke that Batman is so physically robust and inhumanly intelligent that he’s practically a superpowered hero anyway, but I admit that I love the aesthetic of “A guy who is just a human, but through focus, training, intelligence, and technology can stand up to all kinds of supernatural things.”
Some writers handle the premise better than others, where he’s just a private detective investigating Gotham’s most mysterious killers.
Johnny from the 2003 movie The Room.
I don’t know if this is ironic or unironic at this point, but he’s absolutely perfect, kind, loving, generous, and caring in every conceivable way. At the flower shop, he’s their “favorite customer” in a way that’s verbally announced to him (implied to be because he gets so many flowers for his future wife™, Lisa), he rents an apartment for a kid named Denny as he works his way through college (and physically saves Denny from an armed drug dealer), his mother-in-law loves him, and
Every bad thing that ever happens in his life is because of some inexplicable betrayal that he didn’t see coming because of his unwavering trust in human goodness (Lisa is a psycho who finds him “too boring”, Mark, his aggressively proclaimed best friend, cheats with Lisa because Johnny’s fianceé is simply too irresistable, and he doesn’t get his promotion at the bank despite making them ungodly amounts of money).
When he finally can’t take it anymore and kills himself, Mark and Lisa kneel over his body and mourn his loss as Mark unceremoniously realizes his mistake and breaks up with Lisa, leaving her abandoned.
Captain America and Black Widow from the MCU movies. They are so perfect that they never change, they change those around them to be better people.
They are protested well and love the friendship they develop but they are just wholly unbelievable.
Yeah but that ass in those tights
I dunno who would be my “favorite” but I’ve definitely got a few:
- Phineas Flynn from “Phineas and Ferb”. Zero meaningful character flaws, but is an enjoyable ray of sunshine
- Sonic the Hedgehog. The quintessential “free spirit” archetype that does whatever he wants whenever he wants and everyone loves him for it.
- Neo from “The Matrix”. Not sure if this counts, but Neo basically wakes up one day from his boring corpo job and turns out to be the Most Important and Most Overpowered person in history who then dies in a very Christ-like fashion to save humanity. I think the saving grace with Neo is that he never buys into his own hype. He constantly doubts that he’s “The One” and never assumes his status is legitimate.
I love all of these characters but dayum they’re peak wish-fulfillment.
I’m not sure I’d even say that Neo is that Sue-ish. If he were, he’d be instantly admired by everyone around him for his status as “The One”, never face any difficulties or setbacks at all, resolve major problems without ever breaking a sweat, etc…
In reality, he struggles to unlock his abilities as The One, is frequently doubted by other humans (or at least, rarely viewed as perfect), struggles to fight the reborn Smith, gets chumped by the Merovingian closing a door on him, can’t stop the machine invasion, is blindsided by the Architect, and ultimately can’t save Trinity’s life.
He’s definitely a messianic archetype character, but suffers enough setbacks I’d not apply the dreaded Sue label.
Bella from Twilight is a total Mary Sue
Does Satoru Gojo count?
Dudes hot, chill under pressure and a proper maniac when the time calls for it.
He’s my fav character of all time, but Roronoa Zoro from One Piece is absolutely THE Gary Stu. Dude never lost a battle since he got one hit from his nemesis turned teachers, every fight that feels like he would lose he just have to visit his memory and remember who tell him what, or made up some shit about resolve then gain new power or stuff. Dude is just overpowered and the only thing that stop him from easy win is the unfair situation stacked against him, not because his enemy is strong. But i guess that’s the best thing about watching his fight, it’s never about overcome the enemy, but overcome the situation.
You could say the same thing for Luffy too. Actually, anime in general are full of characters exactly like this. Characters that you know should never have had a chance winning a battle or saving the day. But leave it to plot commanding it or writer’s favor, they pull through.
One thing I like about one piece is that there are times they lose and need to be rescued. Right before the time-skip is one example.
Its not the most common, but they do lose or need to flee from time to time. Additionally, they also show them training a lot, so progress isn’t exactly unearned.
Yuri Lowell, Tales of Vesperia
There's an arc midway through the game where one of the villains gets caught, only to boast that as a noble, he's above the law so the courts won't touch him. Knowing there's nothing else they can do to him, the party turns back and heads to an inn for the night.
While the rest of the party is asleep, Yuri sneaks out to go for a walk. He just so happens to bump into our villain. Noting that there are no witnesses around this late at night, Yuri decides that if the law won't administer justice, he will.
That game’s story was so horribly disjointed and I never finished, but I did appreciate that scene
I hope you at least got to the part of the game where the “gentleman” enemies started to appear. Best Tales beasts ever.
But yeah that game’s story was definitely all over the place.
Superman. He is such a good character.
I’d argue that a Paragon is a separate species from the Gary Stu, specifically in Superman’s history of being purpose made to steal the term from Nietzsche obsessed Nazis and turned into a defender instead of an oppressor as a deliberate criticism of their philosophy.
Definitely related species though.
Does Maomao from Apothecary Diaries count?
Nah, she’s pretty seriously flawed. Just in that useful to the ruling class kind of autism way.
Wesley Crusher. he gets a lot of hate but I feel it’s undeserved.
okay, right up until the space natives ascend him. that shit was ridiculous.
Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind. Her one weak moment in the movie is a crash out from realizing she’s capable of killing. Otherwise, she not only avoids but deescalates conflict where possible, is brave and self sacrificial to a fault, and displays a worldly curiosity that turns out to be key to the apocalypse she lives in.
She basically gets no character growth, and much of the movie is the rest of the conceited cast realizing how great she is.
+1
Also the manga for Nausicaa (the original source material, also written by Miyazaki) is much more explicit about Nausicaa being basically a Christlike figure who is supposed to be perfect
I got Goku. He’s basically a Gary Stu. He only makes one mistake which is letting Cell get a single inch near Gohan.
The guy famous for dying all the time?
I mean, he is very much a Gary Stu, it’s just wild to call it one mistake.
Professor Tellwyrn from The Gods Are Bastards was created as an exploration of the Mary Sue trope - specifically, how would everyone else around her see someone who always wins and is (almost) always morally and logically correct?
She’s seen as arrogant, brash, insulting, powerful, often condescending, caring, brilliant, and dangerous. Most people are nervous around her, though some assume her reputation is overblown (and almost always suffer for it). Governmental organizations similarly try to keep her placated and distracted, and avoid interacting with her directly. When they find she’s got a new focus, they immediately start working on damage control, because she’s going to be ruining someone’s day, and after centuries of experience, they realize it’s best to just treat her as a kind of natural disaster.
She does have friends and allies, though - largely people with power and connections themselves. These aren’t people who always agree with her, and they will often push back on her; but they often have a point themselves and work to mend things after.
I am genuinely having a hard time thinking of any characters that would fall under that context off the top of my head. Even after reading comments here. So, would Agent 47 outside of games like Absolution and more in the normal formula count? Because if so, I cannot think of like any other example and I just like how he’s basically perfect at everything he does in certain missions, like drumming, fortune telling, house tours, etcetera.
Agent 47 is an interesting case, mainly because I have a hard time even thinking of 47 as a “character”. I can’t speak to Absolution, but otherwise, he’s basically just a vehicle for gameplay with a minimal tragic backstory around him, and his extreme proficiency at literally everything is played as a lampshade that you’re playing a video game.
You’re more or less playing a robot with a skinsuit.
Nia from Gurren Lagann. The first time I watched it, I was kinda surprised at just how indulgently it felt like she was written. Like the main character literally opens a box and this innocent-but-wise beautiful virginal maiden comes out who unconditionally loves the main character after spending 15 seconds with him. She looks like an angel, she’s literally a princess, and she’s so perfect and clean that it feels irreversible to see her step out of her box into the imperfect, unclean world that the other characters know. Like the Buddha leaving the palace.
Just a perfect Mary Sue ex machina. But also an awesome character.
Probably batman.
I know some iterations have him dealing with more flaws but I personally enjoy a dude with some basic tech and a little prep time being able to take down the universe’s greatest threats.