Google is sabotaging their OEM partners by making a growing number of features and updates exclusive to Pixels. At the same time, Google is trying to convince OEM partners not to support GrapheneOS or even bootloader unlocking. They're also trying to harm GrapheneOS directly.
FIDO2 and passkeys can also be used without Google Play. We had a workaround to make it work with Google Play and could have worked around the other stuff too but it's nice they implemented this. Google's engineers are not the problem. Their business people are the problem.
Google's business side is actively trying to wipe out alternatives. Google Mobile Services licensing has many illegal terms aimed at preventing competition. That isn't enough for them. They're very directly trying to harm GrapheneOS in multiple ways and outright wipe it out.
The current situation is serious. We're very interested in talking to @AGToddBlanche and others in a position to take rapid action against Google's escalating anti-competitive behavior. They're taking increasingly extreme actions to wipe out alternatives and action is needed.
There have been multiple lawsuits by the US DoJ against Google for antitrust violations with Android. Those have barely touched on the most egregious criminal antitrust violations which are currently rapidly escalating. We're interested in talking to @TheJusticeDept about it.
We expect Google will begin bootloader locking Pixels, continue heavily pushing the illegal Play Integrity API and trying to make forks of AOSP non-viable. Many of their actions are clear violation of US criminal law. US antitrust law even includes prison time for individuals.
Recent actions by Google have made it clear they're actively at war against alternatives. Our community can help us get in touch with government prosecutors and regulators. We have the resources, support and tools to continue regardless of Google's actions but won't do nothing.
Google has been repeatedly reaching out to OEMs to question whether they're working with us and threaten them based on GMS licensing terms found to be illegal by multiple courts. They're trying to stop us from having more than Pixels to support. It's completely outrageous.
@GrapheneOS
I would love to see is a real third option for mobile OS’s. Graphene working with @jolla Sailfish OS, @ubports Ubuntu Touch, or @mobian would be awesome. Put some better security into the more mainline Linux kernel for mobile OS systems. Maybe we could actually get some competition into this hell hole market. Pipe dream, probably.
I could also put my money where my mouth is and pick up a device or two and work on app ports for Linux phones, I suppose.
When that 25th hour of the day and 8th day of the week come around, I’ll be all over it. 😅
@jeffcodes Each of those is drastically less private and secure than the Android Open Source Project. It would be rolling back an enormous amount of progress for both compared to traditional desktop operating systems. None of those have anything to do with using a mainline kernel. Those don't have anywhere close to the usability, battery life or app compatibility to be a serious competitor either. We want to be moving away from insecure legacy software rather than moving more towards it.
I’m well aware of that, and I get it. Though, if no one ever does the work to have a viable third, fourth, or fifth mobile OS, we’re only going to get further locked down two-party options. Apple will never open up, and Google is doing all it can to move in that direction.
Data is still king, and the last vestiges of data harvesting require more closed systems for profit increases. At some point, I’d just love to see something else with security and privacy focus come into play.
I’d love to have a real third option not tied to Google or Apple.
Graphene’s mission is to secure Android, and probably isn’t the right player anyway. I’m not a mobile or low level security developer either, so I can’t contribute without a lot of retooling myself.
Anyway, all that to say, I’d just like to actually have choice rather then the illusion of. I love what y’all do, and I donate to support you and will continue to do so.
@jeffcodes Our mission isn't to secure Android. Our main mission is to create a private, secure, usable, compatible and robust operating system for personal computers. Our focus is on our own project and userbase.
Our starting point was mobile devices but we aren't specifically limiting ourselves to being a mobile OS.
We're providing a great option in the present while building the team, tech and resources we need for what we want to build in the future. We'll keep getting much better.
@GrapheneOS sounds like monopolistic behaviour.
we do have laws against that in the eu. did you raise a complaint with the eu dma team?
or the canadian competition bureau ?
@GrapheneOS What would stop them going after users for unauthorized use of Play Store?
@GrapheneOS yeah, just had my state's digital ID provider tell me they won't support GrapheneOS (Play Integrity) because they only support "standard operating systems" 😕
Small wonder. If I were working for #Google, that would be the most logical strategy.
I think the more interesting question is: Why did they provide you with the possibility to install another OS (#GrapheneOS) in the first place.
Other than that, it is appalling and exasperating.
And if the idea was to enter the military market, etc., what went wrong?
This is going to lead to more boot loading,
As in booting people from the smartphone concept and loading up their lives with real things.
Smartphones, if I had to say, are, at their core, devices specialized at being a gate between our eyes and our actual experiences.
A gate that can, and has been, hijacked.
@GrapheneOS Saw this coming when the product exclusivity emerged - need drivers for all of the other devices..... 😮💨
@GrapheneOS
That is horrible.
And very ironic for a company who’s slogan at some point in the past was “Don’t be evil”
@GrapheneOS seems like a lawsuit in the making.
@GrapheneOS Hope u peeps persevere, ur my next o/s, if ur still around
@Ox1de We'll still be around. We plan to outlive Android.
@uriel We explained exactly how they're doing that in our thread. They're contacting OEMs trying to scare them into not working with us.
If Google wasn't a bad actor engaging in egregious violations of antitrust law, then they'd be happy to work with us and make their apps and services fully available as regular sandboxed apps on GrapheneOS. They would be happy to build sandboxed Google Play themselves instead of us doing it. They should want their apps and services everywhere, shouldn't they?
@uriel Google has played the same anti-competitive games against everyone in the space. They heavily worked to crush serious competition including Microsoft's entry in the space. They wield their monopolies as weapon to reinforce and expand each other. They'll stop people using YouTube in order to force them to use everything from Google. iOS only gets special treatment because it was already so established. They'd definitely try to kill it too if they had a more advantageous position over it.
@GrapheneOS What we need is a code repo hosted in the darklands, ie. not github or bitbucket etc, where people just start making tools to rip Google software (and I include Chrome, oh do I include Chrome) apart and completely deliberately violate all terms of service. It's got to the point we need to do this, it's just interfering in peoples' lives too much and the alternatives are underresourced.
@GrapheneOS
It's because GrapheneOS a better than google and google is hell bent on identity theft of all who use AOSP. Just Tom Clancy's Power Plays but in real life. I recommend Graphene to most people. GrapheneOS is what a phone OS should be. I tell people to delete their Google environments, accounts and request all data deletion (or, at least not be findable through google) through their request form.
@GrapheneOS Probably most of those pixel "features" are ai based shite. I wonder how much influence Google has with the Chinese makers - China clearly has Drumpf in their pocket.
@GrapheneOS, the community is on your side!
What, in your opinion, is the reason for this aggravation of the problem right now? Is it the growing number of users of GrapheneOS?
@GrapheneOS Use open source to build your fortress, then pull the ladder up behind you and start shooting at open source from behind the walls.
@GrapheneOS So, Google straight-up admitted to killing alt Android, right after MS announced new integrity requirements for Windows which could jeopardize Linux on the PC, surely that's just a coincidence....
There are a lot of engineers at Google who support what we're building and have directly worked with us. People there have repeatedly helped us and even explicitly added support for GrapheneOS to Google software including supporting Vanadium for Play services FIDO2 and passkeys.