I see a lot of snarky quote-posts here, but I do not see the "alternate vision" Brendan asked for. In a world where LLMs are clearly accelerating discovery in math and theoretical CS—and where 56% of US adults use them weekly—what is the plan? Is it "wait for this to go away," as "fad" suggests?
RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:ywlagohauh5cgwmspgnrpd2o/post/3n2mtsdjc4k2j
1 Boost
0 Likes
Some studio art and humanities disciplines will lean into in-person analog practices, and there will be students who want that.
Math, CS, bioinformatics, medicine, &c are definitely not going to do that. No amount of hectoring will make them do it: it would be disciplinary suicide, since knowledge
production in those fields increasingly involves AI.
Can we not just declare a truce, accept that there is not going to be any "university-wide policy about proper use of AI" — because it is neither going away nor becoming universally compulsory — and get on with our specific jobs?
Is it "Build a wall around university campuses and tell all students that they must spend four years learning only traditional artisanal practices of knowledge production?" If I were 18 I would not sign up for that.
I think this is the de facto plan: different disciplines handle this differently.