I'm a technologist not an academic but while the technology is not IMO a fad, it's use as a general purpose machine for doing everything including education with very much is a fad.
A product of gullible rubes being persuaded it is possible & desirable to replace thinking with probability matrices
RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:ywlagohauh5cgwmspgnrpd2o/post/3n2mtsdjc4k2j
A key example to set things clearly - LLM reflects biases and prejudices latent in the prompts it's given and generally tends to agree with the prompter. As such it doesn't have an independent point of view (because it can't, it's not part of its design to have one).
Because of this it is strictly inadequate for tasks an educator might engage in like dialogue or asking good questions of a student to help provoke critical thinking skills. It's incapable of having that relationship of being a whole other human being with expertise, experience & a different pov.
By nature when you ask LLM something it can also generally only answer in terms which are the most generic possible as it has to guess what you meant in the semantic gaps everyone leaves undefined in the hope of shared meaning making or just because the questions were half baked.
Because of all this, it is difficult for it to really help you explore things in areas where you don't know what you don't know. The probabilistic nature of it means it'll seem like it maybe is a useful tool - at least for the phase of learning where you do not know shit about what you're learning
The critics of this belief system (to my knowledge @olivia.science@bsky.brid.gy and @irisvanrooij.bsky.social@bsky.brid.gy among others) have described it as "connectionism".
The idea that a big table of probabilities can turn intelligent if it encodes a sufficiently complex and expensive set of connections between things.
The thing is these things have a kind of automatically encoded "knowledge" in a vague and lossy way which can get very limited practical work done (usually with very low computational efficiency) without any kind of judgement or independent mentality at all to them other than a superficial role play
And the difference between intelligence and an impressive accumulation of compressed knowledge is actually really fucking significant and keeps going missing in these conversations.
Important correction that "connectionism" is the name of the belief system underlying a lot of probabilistic artificial intelligence systems not just a word used by critics.
RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:vsyj5jtayxcq5dw5mtja4xtb/post/3n2nja6q6ec2j
Separately but also relevant to education there's also the issue that without practicing working against friction for most human beings it's hard to build up a tolerance for persevering against friction (such as difficulty completing hard intellectual challenges) sufficient to be useful academics.
As someone who works daily with the technology trying to wrestle with what it is or isn't useful for, the thing that's obvious to me is that handing over your cognitive processes to be imitated by it is the single worst way to use it, if there is any use for it in your field of application.