Since 7 years I have been following the #ICJ case #TheGambia vs #Myanmar. The verdict is expected 19/11/2026. This is a highly significant day for all #Rohingya. If you are new to the case, start reading from this 🧶 for a summary & links to #whatshappeninginMyanmar
#genocide
bsky.app/profile/judi...
RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:o7mqzu7aleiaz4hi44hod7x2/post/3mc65brmmqk23
Für deutschsprachige LeserInnen: meine Meinung 2022, warum die Generäle von #Myanmar den #ICJ im eigenen Interesse gebrauchen, um sich als legitime „Staatsvertretung“ zu generieren:
taz.de/Der-IGH-der-...
Und von 2023 nochmal in der TAZ warum sich Deutschland davon nicht blenden lassen und sorgfältig zwischen Militär und rechtmäßiger Regierung unterscheiden sollte. #Myanmar
taz.de/Deutschlands...
#Myanmar is a country, for whom dictators continue to speak in international fora such as the UN and the ICJ. Imagine what type of leadership it takes to make positive (!) use of being accused of having violated the Genocide Convention. For Min Aung Hlaing it’s an opportunity to perform as “state”.
A lot of eyes are on the #ICJ today. For different reasons.
1. #Rohingya expect justice for the atrocity crimes committed against them
2. #Myanmar |s population wants to free themselves from those who, after killing Rohingya, continue killing other civilians
3. #SouthAfrica vs #Israel will watch…
… because today’s decision will pave the way for their case, too, esp. regarding the logic of the court’s reasoning
4. All legal experts and people like me will watch also because we want to understand how the court will infer (or not) genocidal intent in light of the evidence brought forward.
The latter point is clothed in incredibly dense legal language impossible to understand for lay people and even non-experts on int. law. But it is necessary to grapple with it because it explains why the threshold to hold a state accountable for having violated the Genocide Convention is so high.
#Myanmar is also represented by legal scholar Prof. Stefan Talmon who firmly sticks to the “only” intent, thus excludes dual intent \ co-existence of intent. In plain words: the killing of #Rohingya as an ethnic group with the intention of commiting #genocide must be the only explanation of conduct.
In light of this approach, the last #ICJ hearing at the beginning of 2026 was incredibly painful for #Rohingya especially who had to listen to legal scholars arguing that, for example, mass rape does not constitute evidence in regard to the issue at hand as it cannot be linked to “genocidal intent”.
For me as a legal anthropologist the reasoning around the issue of “genocidal intent” is a particularly prominent example of why lay people’s understanding of justice inevitably clashes with what is happening at a court such as the #ICJ. The stakes are not only high, they are partly incompatible.
The session is open. It is held under the presidency of Judge Iwasawa Yuji, President of the Court, as the previous sessions were. #ICJ #TheGambiavsMyanmar
Judge Iwasawa Yuji lays out formalities and emphasizes that the only evidence taken into account is that brought by the two parties. Also: "The court found the witnesses credible ... many of the statements were unchallenged in cross-examinations ... largely consistent with other evidence"
Judge Yuji continues listing different sources: the court gives "considerable evidentiary weight" to satellite images. It also relies on other UN materials and takes into account reports of NGOs, "recognizing lower evidentiary weight".
Also: Expert witnesses within the scop of their mandate.
"The court places its main focus on the clearance operations of 2017".
"The Court finds that ... #Myanmar 's security forces engaged in indiscriminatory killings ... sexual violence and the deliberate burning of #Rohingya homes ... killed 1000s of Rohingya civilians ... acts of extreme violence against children and fleeing Rohingya ... to #Bangladesh."
"The Court has indicated that the term 'destroyed' refers to the physical/biological group rather than the group's culture ...
Forceful transfer of children does not necessarily lead to the destruction of the group, but ... can have consequences for the group's capacity to renew itself."
The Court just recognized the #Rohingya as a 'distinct ethnic group' with their own culture. They acknowledge the Rohingya's self-identification as an ethnic group.
The Court finds that the Rohingya have a particular group identity and qualify as a protected group for the purposes of Art. 2 of GC.
The concept of "mental harm" is taken into account now. The way I read the last 20min of the Court's statement, a wide/r interpretation of 'genocidal intent' is being pursued here that is not limited to the physical destruction or even to 'precise extent of injuries suffered or number of victims'.
But: "The Court is NOT convinced that the evidence sufficiently establishes that the restrictions ... described by the applicant were objectively capable of bringing about the ultimate death of this group" and "clearance-operations did NOT impose conditions" as required under Art2c GC.
"Widespread acts of sexual violence may constitute measures aimed at preventing the reproduction of this group ... with respect to intent, the Court considers that the likely effects would have been understood by Myanmar's security forces who perpetrated them in light of the circumstances."
The Court finds that taken together the restrictions on birth ... denial of registration of Rohingya children and the large-scale rapes during the clearance operations ... when viewed in the context .. establish an INTENT to impact the capacity of the group to reproduce normally...
In sum: The Court considers that #Myanmar 's security forces COMMITTED ACTS under Arts 2 a, b, and d of the Genocide Convention. The evidence does NOT conclusively establish intent in regard to Art 2c.
The International Court of Justice #ICJ which is the principal judicial organ of the United Nations, will convene at 10am CET. You can watch the session live here:
webtv.un.org/en/asset/k17...
THE HAGUE – The International Court of Justice (ICJ) delivers its Judgment in the case concerning Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (The Gambia v....