ah dang last.fm scrobbler hasn't been running for who knows how long. also last.fm is terrible. there needs to be an easier way to import my listen history from iTunes into whatever else.
@alisynthesis I am well aware of listenbrainz. I have it fed from my last.fm scrobbles but listenbrainz is still just as much of a mess as last.fm when it comes to actually matching metadata to things
@alisynthesis also listenbrainz has had *awful* performance for a while because they've also been hit by the massive AI crawler onslaught that's destroying the independent web :(
@fluffy ah, bummer. I will admit that I pay exactly zero attention to my scrobbles, LOL. Probably should have turned it all off years ago.
things like this make me just think about how futile it is to do scrobbling to begin with and I should just go back to doing weekly "what I'm listening to" blog posts
one of the long-term goals I have with the mecagorp/chorus project is that having a unified library and player makes scrobble aggregation easier, but it still doesn't solve the hairiest problems
Some of the problems with scrobbling in general:
1. Can only really properly match content that is already known to the system (and there is no discography on the planet that is even remotely close to complete)
2. Multimodal listening is a fucking *mess*, especially when it comes to linear music streams
3. Even when stuff does have good metadata, doing a metadata match is always super imprecise aside from things like musicbrainz (but musicbrainz isn't universally supported and see point 1)
Listenbrainz is the least-bad of the systems in that it tries to match things to Musicbrainz items, but Musicbrainz is *woefully* incomplete and inconsistent, and very few players and scrobblers actually support Musicbrainz metadata.
And linear streaming is a huge problem just because nobody can agree on how to provide the metadata and whenever there is metadata it's usually in the form of a transitory sidecar that's not referenced by the stream itself.
That last one is pretty maddening because embedded metadata has been a thing for *ages* in shoutcast and icecast, buuuuuuuut none of the "real" broadcasters use that, and also the embedded metadata is usually pretty lossy because it's still the case that nobody knows how to tag their fucking mp3s even in the year 2026
@fluffy metadata is also just reallyโฆ personal. my absolutely correct way is likely different from my friendโs absolutely correct way.
@brhfl There are objectively correct ways of providing music metadata, but they require a lot of attention and care and understanding the respective spec, and I've yet to meet a media player that actually gives a shit about anything other than artist + album + title and *sometimes* album artist.
@fluffy yeah iโve had to put a lot of effort into getting software i use to pay attention to sort fields and the like.
@fluffy sigh yes. we remember when we were young and naive and were huge fans of the idea that we could all crowdsource cddb together and someday it would be comprehensive
and then, of course, that corporation took all the data and discontinued the public-benefit activities. fuckers.
@fluffy Yeah. I use Libre.fm now it's back; but scrobbling from multiple devices sucks. Last.fm or nothing from the iphone, from what I can tell. Really need an iTunes alternative that's cross platform. Wish Dropbox could actually store files on the iPhone instead of being a shim to the browser; could actually _build_ something then.
@vonExplaino so that's one of the long-term theoretical goals of Mecagorp/Chorus but getting there from here feels intractably complex right now
@fluffy have you checked out Listenbrainz?
(Don't know anything about this website, but the post seems to be a fair comparison.)
https://www.theodorehq.com/echo/blog/posts/lastfm-vs-listenbrainz
Last.fm vs ListenBrainz: Which Scrobbler Should You Use?