I wonder if there's an EU alternative to LetsEncrypt?
Not because anything bad happened. But you never know.
I wonder if there's an EU alternative to LetsEncrypt?
Not because anything bad happened. But you never know.
@scy Well it's nice there's an alternative, I do wonder if this needs to be something that an independent org should do, or perhaps more than one.
@onepict That would be awesome, but becoming a CA is not a trivial thing to do.
I mean, before we had Let's Encrypt, CACert was already giving out certs as a community project. Not sure how operational they still are, and what the browser/OS support realistically is like.
@onepict actalis.com (italian)
@onepict I haven't used them, but have got https://zerossl.com/ bookmarked for that sort of eventuality. They're Austrian it seems.
(And have also bookmarked Actalis now too, thanks to this thread 😄)
@amcewen I figured it was worth asking the question.
@onepict There was (is? site seems to be down) cacert
@onepict we could have uses SSL4EU … (like DNS4EU) ..
But that name is already taken 😉 by something else :
@becha I feel like this is something that @nlnet may have to have a think about with the Commons Caretakers.
Because @forgejo is an @NGIZero funded project and for that to happen to Codeberg which is the organisation that looks after them is a supply chain issue.
Forgejo can't put out a security update at the moment easily.
@onepict Like others, I moved to actalis from letsencrypt, about 3 months ago. All good, no bad… so far.
@onepict this is actually really good contingency planning
@cyberquixote our internet is a bunch of hacks. We'd never factored certain requirements into its design.
It's no wonder we end up at centralised services. We also need to factor in the political reality of our leaders whims. Or DMCA takedowns as we saw today with codeberg.
It's nice we have an alternative, but I'd like something that was an independent alternative. Because sanctions can hit organisations and people easily.
So I thought I'd ask the question.
@onepict we definitely need other letsencrypt style services now, but we also need to get back on mozilla's and google's case about supporting dane (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNS-based_Authentication_of_Named_Entities) so we can free ourselves completely from certificate authorities.
it puts another piece of infrastructure in the dns, but since we need the dns to work for the existing tls infrastructure, it's no net loss.
and, maybe, someday, we can have true decentralized dns, and this will come along for the ride.
@onepict The only ACME providers I'm aware of are these: https://acmeclients.com/certificate-authorities/
And unfortunately, *all* of them with the exception of LetsEncrypt add bullshit to the process for no benefit to the user. Actalis apparently only allows one domain per account, too.
I like LetsEncrypt but it would certainly be nice to have some diversity in ACME certificate issuers, so we don't have a giant SPOF dangling over a large chunk of the Internet… but that does seem par for the course.
@onepict Actalis does free ACME certs, but you need to register an account with them.
https://www.actalis.com/news/ssl-communications/free-and-unlimited-dv-certificates-actalis-becomes-europes-reference-point-for-acme-based-web-security
Edit to explicitly say: I'm using them on most of my domains and it works fine. It's a bit more work to set up because you need to give your server(s) the credentials to authenticate with the Actalis servers, but that's basically a one-time thing and no big deal.
https://chaos.social/@scy/117294415862383621