I am not the only one that thinks that Godot anti-AI policies have turned toxic. The maintainer of the amazing Godot Rapier plugin quits:
https://www.reddit.com/r/godot/comments/1xyrte5/about_the_future_of_godot_rapier_and_ai_usage/
I am not the only one that thinks that Godot anti-AI policies have turned toxic. The maintainer of the amazing Godot Rapier plugin quits:
https://www.reddit.com/r/godot/comments/1xyrte5/about_the_future_of_godot_rapier_and_ai_usage/
@prozak yeah, gatekeeping is one part. But it snowballed from “we want human reviews” into outright bans left and right.
Posts deleted, can’t link to ai resources, comments removed on discord.
@Migueldeicaza it will fade a way… it will fade away. We are on the uphill and it will settle, hang in there, what you do is appreciated.
That or skynet will arise…. LOL
@Migueldeicaza I, on the other hand, will agree with the comments there, stopping support for work that took a long time and was supposedly done with no AI just because the community decided to reject AI is myopic and just looks like a way to "ransom" the community into accepting something it doesn't want to.
Typical weird LLM-booster behaviour and speaks more about them then it says about the community.
@joojmachine Read the other comments, in particular his replies, because that comment is ill-informed.
@Migueldeicaza @joojmachine I think it was based upon what he wrote, which included the assertion he wasn't using AI.
And then he posts a reply that doesn't mention AI at all.
And then later in the thread he admits he's been using AI for the last year?
So basically he's quit because he's been using AI despite the community's wishes not to include AI generated code in Godot - a very good decision given the current questionable copyright state of genAI code.
In the mean time you're saying he quit not because of that, but because of "toxicity" in the Godot community. That I can't speak to, but he hasn't mentioned anything about toxicity or anything close to it.
Basically Godot set a rule. A very reasonable rule until the copyright situation is clarified. He broke it. This is not an example of anything other than maybe follow the rules when they're reasonable.
@poundquerydotinfo @joojmachine he uses ai, he mentioned that somewhere
@Migueldeicaza SceneSprockets is over here saying “hi handsome”!
@Migueldeicaza am I understanding right that this is specifically about Reddit, or the Godot open source project as well?
@mattiem it is complicated. A bit of a slippery slope.
Godot said “we are overwhelmed by AI patches”. That turned into cheering, so it became “no AI patches (footnote)” and that became “no ai in foundation forums” which became “the use of the word ai is verboten” to “abusing ai users is ok”.
Even on the official dev rooms you get scolded for mentioning The Words That Must Not Be Said.
It is exhausting.
@Migueldeicaza I think is, at this point, a forgone conclusion that society fractures into AI/non-AI groups. It’s such a terrible thing but I do not know of way to stop it…
@mattiem for a while. This is a horse -> car moment.
@Migueldeicaza Shades of anti-vax hysteria there.
@schwa @Migueldeicaza You did **not** just equate opposition to generative AI to opposition to vaccines.
@eschaton @schwa I can see the similitude. There is a wide spectrum of reasons to not like AI.
There is one entire slice of the criticism that is deeply uneducated and rooted on hearsay.
There are other slices, but when that slice comes up, you know you are better off boiling rocks until they become tender.
@Migueldeicaza @schwa And just what slice is that?
@Migueldeicaza @schwa Of course the good reasons to ban it from projects are that its creation was done in a fundamentally immoral and unethical fashion and nothing one can do can decouple it from that, and that their output is always fundamentally a regurgitation of their input which means it’s chock full of license and copyright taint.
@Migueldeicaza LOL at the idea of “toxic” anti-AI policies. Butlerian Jihad now.
@Migueldeicaza oh man the comments on that post. I don’t blame him for leaving.
@Migueldeicaza I am in no ways an AI evangelist. AI is a tool in all its flavors.
But many communities are taking the gatekeeping stance, instead of allowing people to use tools and collaborate with safe guardrails, it seems many communities are now gatekeeping whilst saying in the past they didn’t wanted gates.
lol, I even moved out of my mastodon instance because of that