i think its ridiculous that everybody seems to be trying to reinvent the concept of a "windowing system" from scratch inside every app and doing a shitty job of it. like browsers have "picture in picture" or "mini windows(??)" or "split views", and like the mastodon web interface used to have the 'new post' in a panel, but now it has a fake modal window, which you can "minimize" and it just goes into the corner of the screen. its like pre-1990 levels of UI design
this sounds insignificant, but twice, with two different people, i have been like "hey look at this" and they start reading the cut-off post above the image that i'm trying to show them, and realize it isn't context, it's just some other thing behind the thing. the problem with UI design is that it's *all* insignificant. it's all about preventing paper cuts, so you can dismiss all of it as annoying edge case stuff that doesn't need to be fixed, even though in aggregate it ruins the experience
i don't particularly like apple, smartphones, or touch interfaces in general, but apple did an enormous amount of testing and iterative prototyping for years before the first iphone in 2007, and i actually believe they already came up with the best ways of doing most of the common interactions. you can bet they tried 5 variations of e.g. "image viewer", including the "image floats on top of app", and abandoned the ones that don't work. the last 10 years has seen people trying to do them anyway
i genuinely don't know how to explain what's changed other than the melodramatic and politically-charged term "cultural decay". i think it's largely the "come up with any old idea and ship it immediately then see if it works" mindset has replaced the "we need focus groups and user studies over a 9-month timeline where we keep trying stuff and throw out the wrong assumptions"
The thing is, most computer UI was more or less perfected years ago through careful Work and now people are just changing things randomly for the fuck of it, which seems to sum up the world of 2026.
I wanted to quote boost this but I couldn’t get it to work. So bummed Mastodon has decided to go down this shitty path.
@deshipu text editing absolutely sucked on iphones in 2007, and when i first got an iphone in 2010 it sucked, and i've used iphones and androids ever since then and it sucks on all of them, and it still sucks now. i don't think i've ever successfully edited text on a phone. there was some study a few years ago about text editing on phones where some respondents were just like "i don't edit on my phone, i write on the phone and edit on a computer" which is the only answer that makes sense to me
at some point the mastodon iOS app changed so that, when you open an image, instead of being displayed full screen on a black background (like every iOS app ever going back to the photo viewer in 2007), it no longer fills the screen, and shows the timeline behind it. so if i hold up my phone to show someone an image quickly, there's a bunch of other stuff on the screen too. so i have to save the image to my phone, then open it, just to show them the image without a bunch of other clutter