Not often I support the mega corporation but...
@ArrestJK They shouldn't use the logo itself, but (much as it pains me to say given who they are) I do think they should(*) be able to say "Lego(TM) brick compatible" and not, as Lego(TM) want, "compatible with major brands". Because "compatible with major brands" is useless to me as a customer, it doesn't tell me *which* major brands, and in fact it would make me suspicious that maybe the reason it's being weaselly is because it's trying to hide the fact that Lego is not one of the brands it's compatible with. Which I imagine is precisely why that's the wording Lego(TM) want.
(*) Pragmatically, not necessarily legally; the main thing I know about the law is that it isn't always terribly sensible or fair.
@zeborah which as the TM says is trade marked so can't use without permission, same way National is suing Mowbray for using their logo without permission (Act allowed theirs to be used)
@zeborah of course that's assuming we live in a country where LAWS apply and clearly given it's being appealed isn't the case
@ArrestJK You can *use* the word Lego without permission, otherwise we wouldn't be able to have this conversation and reporters wouldn't be able to report etc. What you can't do (to simplify greatly because 1 I'm definitely not a trademark lawyer and 2 law is complicated) is use it *in a way that might mislead/deceive/confuse the consumer* - so Zuru can't slap it as the main header on their boxes as that would reasonably be expected to mislead people into thinking they're buying actual Lego bricks.
But the Court of Appeal clearly felt that simply stating that the Zuru bricks are compatible with Lego bricks does more to inform the consumer than to mislead them. I guess the question for the Supreme Court is whether the statement somehow implies that Lego have approved the connection.
@zeborah Can use the word Lego in the same way you can use the word National You CAN'T use them in an Ad
Can't use the word and LOGO or the TM name
@ArrestJK Re not using them in an ad -- again it's not that simple. Eg S94 of the Trade Marks Act says "A registered trade mark is not infringed by the use of the registered trade mark for the purposes of comparative advertising" (with caveats which are probably being discussed furiously with respect to this case) and S95(d) allows for use of the trade mark "where reasonably necessary to indicate the intended purpose of the goods (in particular as accessories or spare parts) or services" (which I expect is also be being referred to, as the reporting actually quotes "reasonably necessary" at one point).
https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2002/49/en/latest/#DLM164681
Re name vs logo vs TM name -- I agree it's probably not going to be considered "reasonably necessary" to use the pretty logo. But re "Lego" vs "LEGO(TM)" (actually, checking the article again, technically LEGO(R) but anyway) -- if you're allowed to use it at all, you *have* to include the (TM)/(R) sign -- the absolute worst thing to happen to a trademark is to be treated as just a normal word without that sign.
Anyway. I don't know how the court will rule. So far one court has ruled one way and another court has ruled another way which indicates it's not a clearcut "this is clearly illegal" thing any more than it's a clearcut "this is clearly legal" thing. Right *now* it is in fact legal to say "LEGO(R) brick compatible", as that's the latest court ruling. The Supreme Court will determine how long that lasts.
@zeborah nothing in law is simple.
Ironically if they succeed under trade mark law, they could be sued under copyright law using their own words in court case against them
e.g. So in this case you claim it was compatible, because it used a similar interlocking system that we copyrighted...
@zeborah but I only have a few commercial law papers under my belt I'll leave it to the lawyers who specialize in these matters I'm sure LEGO has a few of them :D
"LEGO® BRICK COMPATIBLE"
From a purely legal point of view: You can't use anyone else's logo without permission just ask National