Twice now I, as a blind person, have used Claude to read my BIOS screen so I could change settings on my own. All it took was a second computer, ffmpeg, and a $20 HDMI capture card from Amazon. Claude would look at the screen, tell me to press right arrow once or down arrow 5 times, then look again to confirm where my cursor was, then I'd press enter and it would look again, and so on.
But sure, let's abolish AI. I was getting way too independent in there.
@TheQuinbox ew that's gross, not only are they ableist but they're not even competent technicians if they can't separate the evils of AI as currently socially constituted from the potential of ML as a technology, including for disabled people. What a failure of both knowledge and imagination. @ernie
@TheQuinbox @ljwrites @ernie ok so, y'all probably know I'm disabled already, so I don't have to go at length about that part, and even so I hate most of the AI shit and the unethical stuff these companies do even if I acknowledge AI is a temporary boon to accessibility.
That being said, I think AI boosters, read, not the people actually using it that much but evangelizing it all the same, will lean on this crutch to push their narrative further, inside our communities and outside it, because it's one more avenue they can take, and they successfully do.
About the uncompromising hate towards the AI stuff, this very much goes the other way too, because the blind community, generally speaking here, has always been too liberal and uncaring, especially because of the whole hardcore christian stuff, which often means few people care about the consequences of anything whatsoever, human rights for example, as long as we can derive even the smallest bit of access from it, even if that doesn't actually benefit us in the long term, which sounds uncomfortably close to that GNU guy last week, who said we should accept code produced using slavery because otherwise we would enter into politics territory.
So for example, most of us wouldn't care whatsoever about the google monopoly, or the apple one, as long as those devices are kinda accessible enough, and we don't often push for more accessibility either, for fear of those companies taking it away from us. It was one thing if people would say they don't know what to do about the monopoly, but it's another for them to not care whatsoever and pretend the issue doesn't exist, or even more hardcore denial, talk about those concerns as childish and immature talk of radicals as an effort to dismiss them entirely.
A good example, also, is LGBTQ rights inside our communities. I remember an incident a few years ago, where a prominent blindness organization said that they will allow LGBT blind people to have a convention side by side with their main event, but at the last possible moment, they did a 180 and said nope. Now that I tried to look for it, I didn't find it, but it's covered in the last few episodes of the living blindfully podcast. This doesn't derive any access, it's just bigotry, but it's relevant because of our general attitudes about things outside strictly accessibility. Or, for example, how many people thought accessibility shouldn't have been included with DEI by Biden, because the maga people will target it too, what a better example of we don't care about anything unless it hurts us personally than that?
So then, back to AI, finally. Look at the audiogames.net forum, even in the dev room where people should know better, AI is evangelized to such a degree that anyone criticizing the companies, the models, anything whatsoever, will be criticized and accused of berrying their head in the sand and not seeing the O so glorious future ahead, where noncoders can just make apps. OK, but what happens when the bubble pops, as it's starting to do now with the nvidia stock issues and the admissions happening recently, and the companies will sell tokens at a closer to accurate pricing for the compute required? what will happen to all that code, which will then be very hard to maintain without the AI because of the way AI codes? what will happen to all those accessibility mods and so on? they might work, especially if the game doesn't change often, but we're one step away from something else breaking inside the stack, and then everything falls apart and nobody would have any idea of how to fix it.
Also take, for example, AI generated audio descriptions. People are using services to do that, then they flood the audio vault with those, and when professional audio describers, or in any case volunteers who have done this for a long while with other shows, notice that there are many things wrong in it, the people adding them get defensive. For one, what use is doing that if the output is very inaccurate? And for another, how would we even know it's inaccurate, or entirely wrong? we may think we saw an awesome movie, the same movie as everyone else, only to have a wrong idea of the story because some details, large or small, were described wrong.
So yeah, in closing, saying AI is horrible and shouldn't exist, it's a fascist tech, etc without looking at the accessibility side of it is wrong, yes. However, the accessibility part works because for years society has dropped the bar on the floor with that one, so anything is better than nothing. But at the same time, what I'm seeing, with the overhiping of this thing because it can do one thing, kinda, maybe, and ignoring all externalities is very very bad, and I think we should talk about that stuff more often and with a more open mind.
@esoteric_programmer @TheQuinbox @ernie Thank you for those very thoughtful and balanced points. If anything I think it's the exhausting disrespect and exclusionism of the tech community and societal ableism at large that drove large parts of the Blind community to prefer even flawed access to the disregard and frustration of decades if not centuries, and as we navigate this new reality it is URGENT that accessibility and the ethos of technology at large be part of the conversation.
@ljwrites > If anything I think it's the exhausting disrespect and exclusionism of the tech community and societal ableism at large that drove large parts of the Blind community to prefer even flawed access to the disregard and frustration of decades if not centuries.
Nailed it. One hundred percent nailed it. As a blind hacker, it is very hard to care about AI in the way sighted people do largely because it finally lets me say fuck you and your ablism, I'm doing this myself. Doesn't mean I don't see the harms, but it's a very hard thing to balance holy shit I can do tasks I was never able to do before with this tech and this tech has actual problems that we should solve. The very selfish part of my brain sometimes even goes well, they didn't care about my access, why should I care about their causes? I of course realize logically that that's an everyone loses situation, but it's a very weird spot to be in, I'll say. @esoteric_programmer @ernie