i recommend everyone read the bible as if you do you will get way more out of reading anything written by a european during the last thousand years. Shakespeare, Camus, Marx, Tolstoy, all those mfs constantly lowkey alluding to bible stuff and expecting u to just get the reference. i mean u could also just avoid reading anything written by a european in the last thousand years but ud be missing out on some buckwild shit
@mdhughes I would say avoid any one guide to it, if one has the time/resources it would make the most sense to look at academic literature related to the specific region/period in question (particularly as the old testament has books written centuries apart from each other) but I recognize this is like, the high effort way of going about it
@Xibanya Almost all other sources are going to be pretty pro-Jesus, & avoid the controversial bits. Only downside is Asimov wrote his book in 1968, so there's been *some* historical research since, but also a lot more conservative theology trying to stop anyone from poking holes in the stories.
@mdhughes there are a shitload of atheist academics writing a shitload about history in the middle east u might have to get a library to get u JSTOR access doe
@Xibanya This is what I didn't get about the 'New Atheists' of a few years ago (as opposed to regular old atheists like myself): They'd often reject ANY mention of religion, even though religion (especially Christianity in the West) has been one of the larger forces that has shaped society itself.
@hermitcl ya nobody is saying you have to believe the bible or find it morally good, it exists and was hugely culturally influential on western thought (and some eastern thought too!), denying that verges on its own weird religious belief
@Xibanya @hermitcl I feel like all religions have a heart of being largely independent attempts at explaining the unexplainable, and as a distressingly clarity-seeking autistic I cannot reasonably complain about this
And they also spark largely independent cultural developments that can be variations of the same fundamental impulse, like how many religions have (and I count Christmas in this, certainly as celebrated today) winter festivals of light based on the impulse of "world dark, add Shiny"
As a secular magpie, I feel the need to celebrate this impulse as broadly as possible, and hence have seasonal lighting up from Diwali to Candlemas and call it the Shiny Season 💖
@shinybat @hermitcl religion has also solved some interesting brain problems. All known cultures have funerary customs, nobody just dumps their dead except in times of crisis. turns out that human brains actually do need some sort of special "ok stop expecting to see this person again" message or they glitch the fuck out. absent knowledge of neuroscience ancient people made up supernatural explanations but they were actually addressing a real need
@shinybat @hermitcl I got gotten by this one. The human brain is lazy and loves using patterns to fill in blanks instead of just doing the work, so if you see someone all the time, your brain just makes you see them if you are likely to and usually it's right so you never notice it was taking a shortcut. Until that person dies. THEN you notice.... 1/2
@hermitcl also a lot of the new atheists saw everything through a Christian lens and would attack eastern religions in a way that made zero sense (like, a lot of animist religions place zero importance on faith/building a personal relationship with the divine, so attacking the morality of their gods is beside the point)
@Xibanya and some of them used their ''atheism'' as a veneer to cover their islamophobia - I wonder how many migrated rightwards
camus: im an atheist. im such an atheist that my entire philosophical framework is going to reject christianity by subverting it so deeply that if u arent already deeply familiar with it u will have no idea what im talking about
marx: im a non religious jew/protestant (long story) and i think religion is bullshit anyway here are a bunch of allusions to biblical patriarchs and the book of revelation to keep things spicy
shakespeare: uh yea i do quote the bible a lot
tolstoy: [sobbing]
@Xibanya My introduction to the Bible was in my first college English survey class for majors. We needed to have passing familiarity to understand the allusions in, well, everything else.
one of the best classes i had in college was a class on old testament prophets taught by an atheist archaeologist who focused entirely on what the text had to say about the society it was written for and spent no time on what the text had to say about modern day. turns out that's where the proto-socialist stuff lives, which is probably why these books are almost never explored in actual church sermons! but u can bet all the euro enlightenment dudes were quoting that shit
i also recommend everyone get super familiar with Greek mythology for the same reasons but this recommendation is less likely to get me some angry person in my mentions being like "well ur entire point is invalid because i was abused by priestesses at greek polytheism school!"
old testament prophets: hey, exploitation of labor is bad (Jeremiah) hoarding resources while others have none is bad (Ezekiel) rich guys buying all the property so normal people can't even buy a house is bad (Isaiah) elaborate religious ceremonies and conspicuous worship while poor people go hungry is bad (Amos)! If u keep doing that shit society is going to shit the bed!
i mean
they weren't wrong!
@Xibanya also to get the most out of the Bible it's best to read it as if you were reading Homer of Aeschylus
@Xibanya But, you're better off not raw-dogging the bible, read Isaac Asimov's Guide to the Bible to learn what all that crap means & where it came from.