I dislike how persuasive I find this argument
@jalefkowit National Popular Vote is largely dumb, and we would do better to ensure all electors were assigned by their states proportionally to their electorate. The biggest problem is that is asking independent states to make their impact less powerful and nobody wants to.
@jalefkowit It’s convinced me.
@jalefkowit I would have to give this a lot of thought. Consider all sides of the equation. I would need to be convinced. Pondering it at this moment, I think it would be a mistake.
@jalefkowit Not sure I agree, but boosting because it raises some points worth discussing.
@jalefkowit It makes some very good points. Dang.
@jalefkowit I too agree. I think the best we get is an agreement between states to each send electors proportional to the votes within their territory.
@jalefkowit this article is ultimately a persuasive one for secession but nobody is ready for that conversation
In the interest of equal time, here’s a counterpoint from Jamelle Bouie
I think Jamelle Bouie is one of the smartest political commentators in the United States of America right now.
Do I agree with everything he says or writes? No. But I think he is very informed and he is often right. Not about everything, as he was very wrong in a recent video about Kegsbreath's impeachment. But for the most part, I really enjoy watching his videos.
@jalefkowit bear with me, I am not American and do not understand the rules.
Why can't you just do without the electoral college?
States count their votes. Then they announce the totals and anybody with a calculator can see who won the popular vote, right?
That's basically how they do it right now, except the number is meaningless because the EC gets in between?
@bleistifterin The catch is that the Constitution (our most basic law) says that the president is to be elected by a vote of the Electoral College, and the members of the Electoral College are to be appointed by the state legislatures. But it DOESN'T say that those electors have to follow the popular vote. As laid out in the Constitution, the popular vote has nothing to do with it. State legislatures can appoint whatever electors they choose, and those electors can vote however they want.
This was all papered over by later state-level reforms which required each state's electors to vote the way the state's popular vote had gone. 38 states and the District of Columbia have these kinds of laws today.
So we can't just ignore the Electoral College, because according to the Constitution it is still the body that chooses the president. Changing that would require amending the Constitution (which is hard to do). What people did instead was add reforms on top of it to try and make it more democratic. Which they did, but not perfectly or completely.
@jalefkowit My initial reaction on learning of the "interstate compact" was that I hope somebody sits down and works out the math of what a bad faith actor - state government, supreme court, whatever - could do, in what scenarios, to use this as a tool for their own ends.
'cause you know _somebody_ has gamed that all the way out.
@jalefkowit The article makes a few different arguments, but I'm guessing you're referring to this one: https://www.nationalpopularvote.com/section_9.29#myth_9.29.1
@jalefkowit The U.S. Constitution is the final boss of technical debt. We've spent 250+ years trying to come up with work-arounds for an 18th century political compromise instead of committing to the slow and painful process of replacing it with something workable for the 21st century.
Which is a roundabout way of saying I agree with Josh.