Long before the Turing Test, there was the Edison Test: from 1915-25, the scoundrel Thomas Edison traveled around the US, setting performers and a phonograph behind closed curtains that were pulled aside to reveal that the music the audience had taken for performance was a recording:
https://www.tomedison.org/blog/edisons-tone-tests
-
If you'd like an essay-formatted version of this thread, here's a link to it on pluralistic.net, my surveillance-free, ad-free blog:
https://pluralistic.net/2026/11/03/nobody-is-home/#metabolizers
1/
@pluralistic Centaur/reverse centaur metaphor useful for thinking how to approach these models.
However, in practice, I find it difficult, because the model intentionally or not flips the interaction upside down. So what's left is the illusion that the user is in control if the tool is used correctly. It's illusion because the house always wins.
And examples of some smart people using this technology at the end supports the model vendors.