my only take on @Mastodon 's redesign is that it is such a missed opportunity to not have done anything with threading in the replies. I've tried reading the comments on a popular post in the default interface (always use Phanpy or custom client normally) and holy shit, the way Mastodon sorts the replies are just so spectacularly bad, i literally don't understand whats going on
@laurenshof @Mastodon Their focus and goals for Mastodon make no sense. @Gargron deserves credit for starting this all but he is singularly holding it back in 2026.
RE: https://mastodon.archive.org/@brewsterkahle/117481215431503956
@Mastodon like, take this thread for example, which has a fairly bad comment section. One reply thread in there immediately dissolves into toxic wasteland. Default Mastodon, including the redesigned version, makes the scroll past 40 bad posts of people flaming each other before i get to see other top-level replies again.
contrast this with Phanpy, which shows enough to know its bad and allow me to read the rest of the comments
this makes Mastodon so much more toxic than it needs to be!
@laurenshof
Demotion, ranking, clustering - over blacklists and defederation. It works. "The Algorithm" is not always a bad thing, it's just used by the bad parties towards the bad ends
@Mastodon
@laurenshof@indieweb.social @Mastodon@mastodon.social I was confused by your screenshot at first, thinking it was Mastodon's new UI. Then I looked at the thread through M.S, and the experience is horrible.
It's like the Mastodon project pondered what aspects of their community caused people to not take them seriously, then decided to double down on making you read every bad comment in every sub-thread first.
@laurenshof maybe something worth mentioning on the Mastodon app design forum?
https://community.joinmastodon.org/
@laurenshof @Mastodon The 5.0 interface is bad and they should be ashamed at this point of having squandered the opportunity they had when Twitter became Nazi central.
But hey at least there’s no AI-generated code in Mastodon.