Some mathematicians, apparently: "it's fine, actually, to stand on the shoulders of Mecha-Hitler*"
* generic term for fash-tech's artificial arrogance chatbots
Some mathematicians, apparently: "it's fine, actually, to stand on the shoulders of Mecha-Hitler*"
* generic term for fash-tech's artificial arrogance chatbots
Such naïveté.
That even some of the sharpest minds (one would've thought) can be such useful idiots.
And not think through what it means to endorse a specific fash-tech product as "intelligence" just because one has either rubber-ducked with it and gotten some useful hints, or used it to generate conjectures or proof attempts.
(I guess the most eager ones expect to be "saved" by getting an evangelist post at one of the fauxtomation forges?
Because this will only result in their departments getting defunded because by crediting(!) the (augmented?) text extruder, the inevitable perception will be that "AI can do it much better".)
Some very good points in here, that should be heeded (or ignored at the peril of everyone).
I have zero respect for mathematicians who work with "OpenAI".
Those proofs can wait.
Can't you see what they're trying to achieve?
There's no fame in helping someone who's trying to monopolize thinking.
Mathematicians collaborating in any way with "OpenAI" and "Anthropic" right now might be smart (or no longer, who knows, considering the effects of these systems).
They're still dumb fucks in the Zuck sense. Tools.
MisAnthropic and ClosedAI are trying to do usefulness laundering with the math problems.
We don't need these companies. The problems will get solved eventually, or won't.
Getting some of these results faster because some craven fame-seekers are "using"* their systems to get these results faster, while allowing them to erase the human effort put into them in addition to the brute-force!, isn't a net win for humanity.
* and completely unaware of being used
Don't collaborate with those whose only goal is to devalue humanity. This should be easy. Apparently it isn't.
I wouldn't have said anything, I wouldn't even have a negative opinion, if they were using systems developed, say, in the universitary context, with a clear understanding that this isn't about destroying humanity and feeding the remains into a data shredder.
But some folks are completely oblivious to the power dynamics and think they're doing the world (or indeed themselves) a favour by letting themselves be used by billionaires? Ouch.
Why do I care?
I'm lambasting them because their unwittingly destructive efforts are so public and getting so much adulating PR.
@quincy I absolutely agree. While it's easy for me to know what the right thing to do is, it's also hard.
I've lost my income as a result of genAI (I teach graphic design) and at the moment the best job offer I've had by far is to help train ai to do graphic design.
I'm not going to do it, but it's scary having no dependable source of income.
I so hope this situation will be over soon and not get any worse, and society will start to refuse the stuff, and people will prefer to pay people instead of these companies again ... 😔
Smart. Adorn its shoulders and help it tread down humanity.