It didn’t though. I see a nice 2.1 audio system with subwoofer, I see ownership of your favourite media, I see gamepads and nice gaming systems.
The phone just provides the illusion of ownership and gaming inputs that hurt your hands, with tin can audio (no matter how many balls they squeeze in those speakers).
That place is cozy, works on its own and can be healthy. A standard phone is designed around the attention economy and to milk you of money and attention, usually dependent on some company. A proper phone that works for you might exist (e.g. Murena, Volla, Nitrokey etc.), but actually owning stuff through it is still hard and ergonomic is shit without addons.
Hardware-wise, if you’re willing to put up with a tiny screen or somehow attach it to a larger screen, all of this was replaced.
I think that’s the main point OOP was making. But, yeah, they also didn’t think about your valid points.
Ah yes, the modern mobile games totally replaced pc and console games.
Technically they added rather than replaced. The majority of the mobile market is people who have and never would play console or PC games^1^
^1^Complete asspulling conjecture
We say cars replaced trains despite trains still being around. The “replaced” refers to the overwhelming majority. Desktop computers are now the minority of Internet users. There are more iphones than Windows desktop computers.
It didn’t replace this:

(I realise that the one in the picture is slightly different. I couldn’t find a picture of the exact same one)
Arguably, these were replaced by screensavers. Which themselves were lost at some point.
I’m interested to hear the argument regarding how screensavers replaced the ooze toy
I could stare at this for hours m.youtube.com/watch?v=vOPoRi5D0uQ&ra=m
Windows 2000 Screensaver - 3D Pipes (4K)
YouTube
I always used the maze one.
Search term “ooze tube toy”

I had that exact same desk! Flat packed garbage, didn’t last 2 moves…
all the wavy lumpiness on the surfaces from the slightest moisture left on for more than 5 seconds.
surviving moves, hell just moving it within the room/house was a test
Oh I do remember the moisture bumps, it was insane how easy it would bubble up w/ the smallest amount of condensation on a can/glass!
You traveled back to my 1998 bedroom! Drop a note to buy Apple stock!
A mysterious note appears by your desk, not in your writing. It says "Buy apple stock."
You wonder if you have ran out of apples and didn't know there was a stock that needed to be replenished.
Is that even your responsibility? You brush the note away, probably it was meant for someone else anyway.
Wait, how do I use my phone as a desk?!?
Replaced? Everything on the picture is worse on the phone. So if you define replacement as embrace, extend and enshitify, then yeah sure
Back when the Internet was a place you had to go log onto, vs a thing always in your pocket and on every device around you all the time.
I acknowledge that for many people, the phone meets most of their needs for personal computer tasks. But I will never understand it. In my mind, the phone is mostly for mindless consumption. The minute I need to get some real work done, I need a monitor, keyboard and mouse. I have friends who handle bookings, online shopping and banking from their phone only. I can do some light managing, but I quickly feel like I’m losing my overview and it’s like having my hands and feet tight up while being held under water. And don’t get me started on watching movies on the phone. I would rather stare into the wall for 2 hours.
David Lynch agreed (30s interview clip)
David Lynch on iPhone
YouTube
I still use my oak corner computer deck - just without the shelves in top.
I just like the layout, and I don’t like buying furniture!

doubt any phone comes with subwoofer, would be hard to hold, and battery would last 5 minutes