in general, the people who you need to listen to re the effects of bigotry or what is and isn't bigotry is the people who are targeted.
unfortunately, this rule of thumb has gotten...complicated with antisemitism.
antisemitism is very real. it affects Jewish people; assuming all accusations of antisemitism are bad faith is really dangerous.
unfortunately just allowing people like Jonathan Greenblatt and Netanyahu to define antisemitism is also really dangerous.
as just one for example, Palestinian people have a pretty important perspective on how accusations of antisemitism are used. Non Jewish Black people (as well as of course Jewish Black people) often do too.
Jewish identity has become a way to validate Zionism and also in many instances a way to validate American identity, and so the convo about antisemitism affects a lot of marginalized people who aren't Jewish.
it's fucked up and the whole discussion around these issues is kind of a nightmare. that's kind of where we are though.
This is all well and bravely put.
We've all seen that no commentary on this topic, no matter how nuanced and carefully grounded in empirical fact, escapes the opportunistic social media blowtorch.
Thank you for taking this risk.
like, yes, Jewish people are important voices. if Jewish people tell you something is antisemitic, that's generally important information.
and/but/also Zionists (Jewish and non Jewish) have turned accusations of antisemitism into a cudgel and a shield to advance a range of horrors.