Am I suppose to just read every book despite a bad cover? There’s a lot of good information on there, and far too many books to read.
Instead of going by the cover wait until two people from different social circles who don’t know each other independently recommend the same book to you. Then even if it isn’t “good” it’s probably something you would like.
its is correct.
“its” is the possessive form, meaning the cover belongs to the book.
it’s is a shortened form of “it is” or “it has”
The only thing worse than a grammar nazi is a grammar nazi who is wrong.
Monty Python’s Flying Circus!
Robert E. Howard created Conan the Barbarian back in the 1930s. The stories were sporadically reprinted for decades, but the character remained a minor figure, far behind the Lensmen or The Shadow.
All that changed when this cover came along…

100% on the mark with your observation, thank you. I will risk throwing in some explanatory prose to go with your point, because I don’t believe it’s obvious enough for all (though I do feel it is self-evidentiary, if one looks close enough)
If I stray from your point, please, do not hesitate to correct me:
A great cover won’t hide a poor book from the audience realizing it for long, but a poor cover will hide a great book from its audience for eternity.
There seems to be a belief in general culture that the adage ‘Don’t judge a book by its cover’ originates as a reader-borne observation, when in reality, it’s a writing floor copium entreaty to the literary gods as whispered by authors without a giant publishing house full of artists to help and a lack of artistic skill themselves.
I felt physical discomfort reading this. Well done.
It doesn’t make as much sense but it made me think of this

I frequently judge books by their cover, especially sapphic books.
If the cover of your book looks like the literary equivalent of a Hallmark movie, I’m going to assume it’s of the same genre and caliber.
I understand there are budgetary constraints, but I would so much prefer a more boring cover to that slop.
The purpose of a book cover is so you will judge the book.
Also, consider old books.