Also, this is a problem about people and social norms as well as the limits of memory. It just happens to also be about math.
@evan I would say option 3 should be 3000, not 3400??
@virtuous_sloth @evan No! It's precisely right to not offer 3000. Obviously, 3000 would be the superior answer, but it would conflate the two competing principles that are tested here: Do we accept the order of magnitude as a correct answer or not, precisely when it does not happen to coincidentally also give 1 correct digit?
@paulbalduf @evan
Are you treating order of magnitude in base 10 or base 2?
@paulbalduf @evan By that reasoning, I'd say the options should be 10000, 1000, 3000, 3200.
@virtuous_sloth @paulbalduf you should make that poll, and I will boost it.
Hah! I chose b) 2000 exactly because it was within an order of magnitude, but farthest off frim 3247.
@evan
I'd be ok with saying "a bit over 3000"
These are:
- off by an order of magnitude
- same order of magnitude
- same order of magnitude, 1 significant digit
- same order of magnitude, 2 significant digits