I have a disagreement with one of the other adult advisors of a club that I run for my school. For years I've advocated for the club to have a budget and for the students to make purchase decisions. I would like them to have a pre-paid card or similar and the ability to order supplies for their engineering projects. The other advisor doesn't want to do this. Instead they have the kids ask one of the teachers to make the purchases.
1/
I think this is a missed opportunity to learn about budgeting. I also think it slows things down too much. It takes time for the school to authorize each purchase and sometimes the students are waiting for parts for a long time.
It's not like the admins say "no" often. In fact they never say no to the purchase requests but sometimes by the time the part has arrived it's too late.
I think the other advisors sees petty cash line as risky but that's kind of the point?
2/