On the other hand (and this was brought up in the article as well), the privacy of E2EE chats depends on how secure the other person you’re messaging chooses to be.
Signal carved out a niche for itself as a secure messaging app, and I wouldn’t say it would be overreaching to implement blanket policies for all users in order maintain that security. Otherwise, your messages are only as private as the other person chooses to be. And if there’s no flag on users who happen to have that setting disabled, the only assumption to make is that all of your messages are compromised by AI screen scrapers.
Isn’t that a matter of trust? If you don’t the other party to protect the privacy of your conversation, the app settings are the least if your issues. They might as well copy it, type it manually into some other app, or paraphrase it to someone who shouldn’t be involved.
It’s always about trust, but now you introduce a secondary layer of trust that is easier to exploit. Previously it was about trusting the other party to not be actively malicious. Now it’s just about trusting them to not be stupid.
I would never expect my parents to go out of their way to surreptitiously send all of my Signal chats to Google/Apple just so the corpos can know everything going on in my life. But I can’t trust them not to use Siri/Gemini, which will just do that on its own anyways.
As long as it’s optional, I love it. I loathe nothing more than when apps force me into a specific security level. Such things are IMO the opposite of data protection, because it takes away freedom to do with my data as I please. So, good on Signal for giving us options to fine tune as we wish.