But how would you know that your non-FOSS software isnt slop?
Then you misunderstand the point of FOSS. Clean-room slopimentations of proprietary software, assuming it is released on a FOSS license, is the very essence of the FOSS philosophy. Make free and open what those that would oppress you do not want free an open.
Don’t get me wrong it’s better to not have slop than have slop, but FOSS Slopware, FOSSlopware, or as I’ve recently taken to calling it, FOSS plus slop is a good thing.
This. One of the big concerns from AI, especially in the early days, was ‘license laundering’; taking copy-left code (e.g. GPL), pumping it through an LLM, and putting it into a proprietary close-sourced product. Slop can’t be copyrighted, under most definitions; but (where applicable) putting slop under such a license reduces those concerns.
I am under the impression that only humans can create anything that can be copywritten.
There is a picture taken by a monkey that set the precedent.
I’m not entirely sure if i consider proprietary software worse than FOSS slop, but i have at the very least started to treat them the same way, as in i only use it if there’s no good alternative.
we use the best tools we have, sometimes we can’t do enough on kdenlive and audacity, unfortunately
that said, I’d push linuxtubers to at least post on peertube
True that, not everything has a FOSS alternative.
*cocks claude* yet 😈️
peertube
Today, I learned about peertube
Thanks.
🪴 🪴 🪴
Stallman’s a creep.
I was a fan of this guy until I read stallman-report.org. Happy to never think of him again now.
If I couldn’t use any proprietary software, I’d have to go back to Windows. The Steam client is proprietary, the games themselves are as well, and so are a lot of the drivers/codecs I need for my system to run properly.
As nice as it would be to be able to rely exclusively on the kindness of strangers who volunteer their time and talents to develop and maintain all the software I need without charge, I just don’t think it’s feasible. As much as I appreciate the unpaid volunteers who are already out there maintaining vital software free of charge, I think most programmers will have to go work for a company at some point because they have bills to pay.
I don’t think the solution to greedy software corporations pushing out expensive sloppy malware that people are forced to use because of walled gardens is to try and replace the slop with a haphazard jumble of completely volunteer made FOSS projects. Instead I think the solution is to reorganize the software company structure. Instead of software companies being owned by shareholders who only care about maximum profits and return on investment, the software companies need to be cooperative arrangements between the people who make and maintain the software and the people who use the software.
Many of the greatest open source projects don’t “rely exclusively on the kindness of strangers” as you put it. Their core contributer base consists of full-time devs paid by some kind of foundation (donated to by corporations), and devs employed by corporations. Good examples are the Linux kernel, Firefox, KDE, etc.
These are projects where the business case to develop something equivalent in-house is completely economically infeasible.
If we want more open source, I think it would be good for governments to make the business case for proprietary software less and less attractive. For instance, by imposing taxes on profits realized with software that isn’t open source.
IMO the end goal should be to abolish intellectual property for software (or in general) altogether, of course.
If we want more open source, I think it would be good for governments to make the business case for proprietary software less and less attractive. For instance, by imposing taxes on profits realized with software that isn’t open source.
If I’m not mistaken, here in the US non-profits already don’t have to pay taxes (obviously because they don’t have any profits to tax), so organizations like the Mozilla Foundation or the Gnome Foundation are already tax free.
I would use non-FOSS software over FOSS slopware