Shame feels like a tempting tool to use to fight back against AI and I see folks advocating for it daily. I understand the temptation. But the reality of "shaming" is that you cannot actually shame another person. Shame is a feeling that arises internally, based on incongruity with one's own values. If you want someone to feel shame, they first have to _agree_ with you that the behavior that they are engaging in is shameful. Hence, as the movie says, "they're not confessing, they're bragging"
Hurting the feelings of your friends who are making a mistake is going to be a much more shameful behavior long-term than acquiescing to some AI use, especially when there's so much social proof for AI use; we will probably regret it. Personally I am doing my best to honestly share my feelings of disappointment and demotivation without pinning it all on the person in question.
There's definitely a lot of stuff in here about masculinity which I am barely qualified to comment on, where it is socially unacceptable for men to express impotence, frustration, and sadness, but A-OK to express rage, contempt, and superiority. So boys are taught from an early age to convert sadness and self-doubt into anger and contempt at every opportunity. That's a momentary balm but it isn't really long-term healthy.
@glyph I thought you were talking about an actual tool called "shame" to do automated reporting/tut-tutting and I ended up finding some actual pro-AI tools called "shame" and "shameo" and so on, and also this ridiculous article that 100% proves your point: https://observer.co.uk/news/science-technology/article/theres-nothing-wrong-with-using-ai-so-why-do-we-shame-those-who-do
@fluffy one of the most baffling patterns in this stuff is how it appeals to middle-aged and elderly people so much more than the youth, on average, despite younger people being forced to use it far more often. so yeah, this does sound like the opinion of an octogenarian media critic, and it is
@glyph Generally-speaking I feel like every generation wants to blame other generations for using it. The only folks I see who categorically reject it along generational lines are gen alpha and later Zoomers, but maybe that's just my own bubble.
Most of the people I know who have embraced it are genX or early-millennial (most frustratingly, my siblings, who think I'm stuck in the past, after previously complaining I was always looking too far into the future).
The thing that you're doing when you attempt to "shame" someone who is doing something they think is morally neutral or valorous is mostly just being unpleasant and insulting. And, again, I get it, you're watching someone do something that you know is harmful, there can be an intense urge to DO SOMETHING in the moment. But the reality is that that person is doing only a tiny fraction of the harm of the real culprits, who you cannot reach.