Yup, I’ve used this argument to win over conservative leaning people to being more pro immigration. You have to be a salesman, not a die-hard if you actually want to convince anyone rather than just yell at a brick wall and tell yourself that’s praxis.
I generally use the economic argument to persuade people against the death penalty, because if someone is for it, a call to empathy probably won’t work.
In the last few years, it’s begun to backfire sometimes, because people suggest removing or limiting death row prisoners’ right to appeal 😬
Is anyone arguing that they’re wrong?
Yes this entire thread
There both modern liberals/ neoliberal/ neocon, all evolutionary descendants of liberalism.
A rightwing conservative is closer to a party Democrat than most anyone on the left. Its not hyperbole or anectdote. Its where the philosophical traditions emerge from.
They’re people, they deserve the same respect as any other human being, immigration is good for some countries when the immigrants are vetted for skills your country needs, but you’re also not required to accept any person into your country. Some countries are more desired than others and population growth via immigration is a tool that has to work for the existing citizens as well. Also, whats with the communist terminology, democracy may not be perfect but it’s the best we have, I don’t trust government to run the country without the threat of an uprising to put those in power in their place and we can use all the help we can get to do that but turning to communism or authoritarianism isnt going to be better that what you have now.
Also, whats with the communist terminology
Bourgeois is the only word there that is associated with communism, and it’s pretty common. I’m not saying this isn’t a communist meme, but that’s more because of the ideas, not the terminology.
democracy may not be perfect but it’s the best we have, I don’t trust government to run the country without the threat of an uprising to put those in power in their place
Communism and democracy are not mutually exclusive. This could also easily be an anarchist meme, and that’s as democratic as it gets.
Tbh my understanding of anarchism is limited to what I had heard when I was a 14 year old. Wouldn’t a system like that eventually dissolve into centralised powers and basically devolve into gang and mob violence.
Democracy degenerating into mob rule is something people have been worried about since democracy was officially codified. The corruption of government of any sort is always a possibility, unfortunately. The only ways to guard against it are to keep the populace perpetually dedicated to democracy, or to create airtight legal structures that prevent people from abusing them.
In practice, neither of those is really possible, so many conventional democracies are currently experiencing huge diversions between what the people actually want and what the government does. This understandably upsets people, so you get protests all over the place. Then of course, you get the UK prosecuting people for charges they aren’t allowed to defend against, French police blowing children’s hands off, and the US tacking secret terrorism charges onto more minor charges without telling the jury what they’re actually ruling on…
while he may be heartless, he's still right, and if you get the right public policy out of it, I'll take it. https://www.economist.com/the-world-if/2017/07/13/a-world-of-free-movement-would-be-78-trillion-richer