I think KDE devs are of the same opinions about layer-shell. There was also talk about restricting what kind of windows can be created with this protocol so that fullscreen overlays are not possible (because they can be abused for nefarious purposes). Not sure if it was implemented.
There was also talk about restricting what kind of windows can be created with this protocol so that fullscreen overlays are not possible (because they can be abused for nefarious purposes). Not sure if it was implemented.
A permission system, similar do Android’s “Allow to appear on top?” is the actual solution to that problem. Disclaimer: No idea if anybody (KDE or otherwise) implemented it.
I suppose. Though there still needs to a user-friendly mechanism to disable such overlay once it’s active, in case overlay blocks all interactions with the OS (intentionally or not).
Damn. I WANT full screen overlays because Borderless Window doesn’t work for half the games I’ve tried
This, so much this. It was the exact same answer I got when I criticized that Gnome somehow managed to screw up screen mirroring - it is impossible to mirror two out of multiple screens, either you mirror all of them or none of them. Such a fundamentally basic feature we already had 20+ years ago, and they designed it away.
Or wallpapers. Guess how you set different wallpapers for different screens. …you can’t.
I don’t know what’s up with Gnome or why they are like this, but the way they caused a whole new DE again (Cosmic) and KDE outright leaving them in the dust they are on the best way towards obscurity.
I don’t know what’s up with Gnome or why they are like this, but the way they caused a whole new DE again (Cosmic) and KDE outright leaving them in the dust they are on the best way towards obscurity.
If you think about Gnome in terms of it targeting some corporate client who cares a whole lot about screen lock, permissions, authentication against some corporate backend, etc, and not at all about a power user running around on their own, then that is one way that can explain why they do what they do. As an example it would be great for a business that needed something one step above a kiosk (maybe like a call center?) I’d love to walk into a DMV or bank and see all the computers running Gnome with a custom app that does all the personal information. That’d be way better than seeing someone flip tabs from their facebook to handle some financial transaction with Windows/Chrome.
The terminal is pretty nice with fonts and scaling, etc, but I don’t know how people use Gnome without the extensions to add back real menus and a program toolbar.
In my experience (admittedly a couple years back) Gnome is horrible for kiosk-style systems. There’s little to no builtin support for basic requirements like hiding the top bar while in non-fullscreen-mode. While there are some plugins, the scripting API is unstable, so plugins might break with any update.
I’d have far more confidence choosing KDE, though a more usecase-specific DM is better.
Then I guess I continue to not understand Gnome’s intended user. I’ve tried using it out of the box, but without real taskbars/menus/min+max buttons the amount of time it takes to swap between windows becomes significant relative to the time I’m going to spend on that window.
I was a Gnome diehard prior to Gnome 3. Apart from a brief stint with Cinnamon I have been hardcore KDE since then. I’ve tried a bunch of other stuff along the way (mad props to System 76 for Cosmic which is genuinely good). I would hate to see Gnome fall further back. We need friendly competition to keep everyone improving and to prevent complacency. I don’t fully understand what the whole issue is here, but I hope for everyone’s sake, it gets worked out.
Also, fuck Discord.
Yes, fuck discord: a problem always trying to become a worse problem.
I’ll try Cosmic someday, and the new KDE as well.
the GNOME maintainers would’ve ripped a huge fart, sniffed it and said “usecase??” while closing the issue, as they’ve done for years.
This issue was opened in April 2019, over the years listing various use cases and the reply was always “Make a Gnome extension”. Gnome’s Mutter is the only non-edge case Wayland compositor not to support this feature: wayland.app/…/wlr-layer-shell-unstable-v1#composi… (and Cage use case is to provide a kiosk, to that feature is probably not support because of that specific use case and for such cases it’s fine)
My pet peeve is this one: gitlab.freedesktop.org/wayland/…/179#note_2965559
(and yes, that’s once again our dear friend Sebastian from the screenshot above)
You don’t get to speak for all users. In fact, wayland was designed to give the compositor and thus user control over this, not the application
removes possibility for user to choose
wat?!
Sigh more gnome bullshut. It’s unfortunate because I like how it looks. Can’t wait for cosmic to be fleshed out
I use GNOME because for me KDE somehow always surfaces the small little annoying bugs (at least on my hardware). But I try every couple of years hoping I can finally switch.
Yeah I’ve definitely had a buggier experience on kde than gnome. My only gnome “bugs” are usually either an extension or the de just randomly crashes sometimes.
I’ve seen some statements with absolutely zero self-awareness, but this is taking the fucking piss. Factorio had to add an additional dependency to get the game to work on GNOME because GNOME refused to implement server-side decorations.
The GNOME dev could have been more congenial but their point is a fair one. Having a major app developer using a private API would mean that any time that private API is changed or removed, the app gets broken and everyone thinks it’s GNOME’s fault. This is the whole reason there is a public/private distinction in APIs.
Discord isn’t exactly a small app developer. They don’t have an excuse not to do things properly.
What private API? Layer shell is a defined spec they just need to pull their fingers out and let the user opt in to it.
It’s pretty crazy how their “solution” is “discord should have talked with us” no the fuck they shouldnt. Should they involve KDE and the Mint team as well then?
Just properly implement the spec ffs.
Exactly this. When I was writing up discover overlay i saw their stance “make it an extension” and decided I didn’t have time to rewrite from scratch to appease Gnome. There’s a workaround or nothing.
Ah yes, API abuse. Which is when you use the API as intended and written.
Gnome devs are completely out of touch.
if its internal, as they said, its not as intended? as the described it, its designed for compositors. which implies, an application using it could lead to conflicting behaviors with the compositor and WM.
This is probably why they’re like “we cant support that” because it’d conflict with what mutter is doing.
doesn’t make it any less a mess but the GNOME devs probably have a point.
wayland.app/…/wlr-layer-shell-unstable-v1
This interface should be suitable for the implementation of many desktop shell components, and a broad number of other applications that interact with the desktop
Suitable. Not strictly, and certainly not private. Everyone else, KDE included, have managed to make this work fine.
I might add that I’m quite well aquianted with this protocol as it comes up in a lot of projects I’m involved with.
Fuck everyone involved in gnome. Yeah dude, discord should have reached out aha I’m sure you wouldn’t have been a nerdy know it all asshole spurned by them not being foss. Mad because of their janky ass desktop api that held Linux back for decades becoming irrelevant.
and you’re bashing everyone involved in gnome because a single person’s comment. gg’s
I am not sure about Sebastian, but gnome can go and fuck right off
Especially Gnome critcizing another projects internal workings or compatibility to others. There’s a term for Gnome’s behavior: CADT (Cascade of Attention Deficit Teenagers). Just look up issues to libadwaita breaking themes or glycin suddenly adding bubblewrap dependency to a wide-spread bitmap library, causong performance issues for lightweight desktops and tooling. All too much skirting responsibilities and whimsies and all too Gnome-centric.
you have too much time on your hands 👀️
In this thread, people who don’t use Gnome getting mad about stuff that only affects Gnome users. If you create an app that needs features unsupported by Gnome then it’s perfectly reasonable to drop Gnome support in response.
Good, much healthier for all people involved and might also lead to real change instead of pointless pissing contests in various bug trackers.
Interesting implication, but you’ll note that I’m not one of the posters to this particular issue.
And since when is “this is a feature GNOME is lacking” a pissing contest? I’ve seen real spam in a bug tracker. This isn’t it.
From a user perspective, gnome is fine. Imperfect but fine and even great in a lot of ways. From a user perspective, Discord is dogshit and that is even if you pretend they didn’t start requiring people to submit face pictures or whatever it was. I won’t be using that bullshit again, but I use gnome daily and I can’t say I have many issues with it.
From a user perspective, gnome is fine.
Gnome is a bare-bones, Android-like experience for me. I tried using it, ended up trying to make it somewhat palatable with extensions, they broke quickly. Most inflexible desktop environment I’ve used, including Mac and Windows.
Many say that extensions are super fragile, which honestly makes sense that they would be… But I’ve probably had good luck with 75% or more of the ones I’ve tried, even if they only claimed to support GNOME versions several years older than mine. I’ve had like 3 times where a major extension breakage caused me a (fairly small) headache. I current have 7 extensions that have been working fine for probably over a year without touching them… I am using GNOME 46, latest is 51 iirc, which one would think would make me very susceptible to extension issues, but I haven’t had one for a long time. So yeah I don’t really have this issue.
Most inflexible desktop environment I’ve used, including Mac and Windows.
I feel like I have customized my setup a lot more than I ever was able to on other platforms, and granted some things were annoying to figure out, then again, I’m quite picky so I couldn’t let many of my preferences go… meanwhile, I tried KDE Plasma again a few months ago. Tried to customize the “task bar” area using the builtin drag/drop UI and the OS crashed out several times. I gave up and declared it not stable (though it was considered a stable release).
I tried KDE Plasma again a few months ago. Tried to customize the “task bar” area using the builtin drag/drop UI and the OS crashed out several times. I gave up and declared it not stable (though it was considered a stable release).
I had that exact same experience a while ago, but it’s gotten a lot more stable since then. Have been on KDE for almost two years now and haven’t encountered that level of jank since. But if you’re happy with Gnome there’s no reason to switch, of course.
“A GNOME developer” I’m gonna stop right there. I use Gnome, but even I know where this is going. . .
As a Plasma user unfamiliar with the politics of gnome, I googled him and… I can see why you already know where that’s going.
As a dev who regularly relies on GTK… I jumped to the correct conclusion
wanna let the rest of the class in on the secret?
why do people still use discord??
they’re literally selling your PII and chat logs to big tech to train fascist supporting AIs.
discord is literally supporting the tech that oppresses you. stop using it.
People use it because it’s what a majority of people use. Not saying it’s good by any means, but most people won’t switch unless the rest of whoever they talk to on there does as well.
I guess people will eat rat poison if the majority does it too.
didn’t think my opinion of society could get any lower, but here we are.
Many people value their social life above being an ideological martyr.
Because there aren’t a lot of clearly-better alternatives. Plus the network effect is strong.
If you haven’t given Fluxer a try yet, it’s worth a spin.
I can’t honestly say it’s fully eclipsed discord on ALL fronts yet (specifically, I haven’t tried any of their non-web clients), but it’s quite close and continuing to bridge the distance.
My friends and I have been using the official instance for a bit under a year now without issue, and I also run a self-hosted fallback server that has been quite painless to manage.
Because every other alternative is straight trash and it is difficult to get entire communities and friend groups to move.
then just…leave the group chat? if everyone just leaves, nobody will use it. and if nobody uses it, an alternative will be made.
This is where content creators almost always go to. Finding a creator who likes my niche taste in games is already hard enough. Finding one who also uses an alternative to Discord? Basically non-existent. I could go to something else for my own friend group, but then I’ll be without the more global ability to communicate about the topics I want to see outside of that.
Unable to decrypt message
i have been daily driving GNOME recently for the first time since the pandemic.
I can see why the community is flocking to KDE. GNOME looks nice and works great with their included apps, but those apps lack a lot of basic functionality. I ended up installing a few KDE utilities (KDE disk partition manager, Dolphin) so i wouldn’t have to keep dropping to the command line for common tasks
Did “disks” not work for you?
it can’t read LVM partitions and can’t change a partition type (only delete and recreate)
There may have been some others but those are the two i remember not being able to do
I loved Gnome3 when it first released. I used it, love the work flow. When they changed to Wayland, discord always was glitchy. I couldn’t handle running it anymore.
I also don’t like the ideals of the devs and the constant breaking of extensions that are necessary. Like systray.
The thing about Gnome apps, for me, is that they have 85% of the features I want with a tenth of the options KDE has. KDE has 90% of the features but 10x the options, making it messier.
But when I come up against a Gnome app being too simple, generally the KDE equivalent isn’t good enough for me either. An example being Gnome Text Editor vs Kwrite/Kate. Gnome Text Editor is fine for a simple text editor, but for more advanced things, like programming or scripting, I want to be using an IDE or *vim, not Kwrite/Kate.
I just really appreciate polish and smoothness, which Gnome has in abundance compared to KDE. And I like COSMIC for having a clean design but more pragmatic decisions than Gnome, but it’s polish and smoothness is still behind, even compared to KDE.
I’m gonna have to steal that first paragraph the next time I’m talking to someone about this. That’s a better summary of my own thoughts than I’ve ever come up with.
Every time I use Plasma, I feel like I have to dig through a thousand options about how fast the taskbar comes up or how jiggly the animations are before I find the basic option that I actually care about. Gnome feels sane by default, and the options I do want are right there.
Gnome makes two terrible mistakes and one of those you hit pretty hard here.
- Just do the thing - GNOME shaves a lot of functionality away to make it simpler. That makes sense if all you are doing is using GNOME apps that plan for this use case, but GNOME is not going to rule the world it’s Linux. It has to cooperate with other things to make sense. GNOME does not do this. Even things designed to enhance GNOME in an intended way (extensions) break with each update. It does not reliably do the thing.
- it tries to subtract everything to conquer all use cases - remember when windows 8 came up with a touchscreen UI, metro? It was a much better touch UI than what came before it, but it threw out everything the already worked for something so narrow in scope it didn’t make any damn sense, even in its intended environment.
i just wonder what the intended use case even is. I’m not a developer, not a sysadmin, not a programmer. My usage of GNOME is relatively non-technical (i sometimes have to flash software onto embedded Linux devices for work, i do amateur photography, i write a little), and GNOME often doesn’t fully cover even my modest use case.
Xfce user sitting in the corner wondering whether this affects me too since I’m not on kde or if it doesn’t affect me because the only thing I want discord to do is let me voice chat and I think any other features are actually kind of annoying.
Dunno about the XFCE Wayland beta, but for stock XFCE, we’re chilling because X11 doesn’t have half baked unstable APIs tied to each DE.
Genuine question, why wouldn’t you just open discord in the browser? has access to much less things then, and you only loose overlays and rich presence
You also lose global push to talk.
Because having an app is convenient? Just because I only use it for voice chat doesn’t mean that additional features make it less usable for the one thing I want. Might as well have the convenience of not having to relog through a website every time I want to use it.
Thank God you added the “genuine question” prefix. That added so much to the question.
GNOME devs when literally anyone touches UX without gargling their design philosophy of “keep it stupid stupid”:
Cool drama. Thankfully that’s not my DE.
the GNOME maintainers would’ve ripped a huge fart, sniffed it and said “usecase??” while closing the issue, as they’ve done for years.