Yeah, their own kids, indoctrinating them with patriarchy and religion.
I don’t care what sort of preaching it is, it all counts for that
Tell us that you enjoy inherent privilege without telling us that you enjoy inherent privilege
Meanwhile every young kid at family gatherings I go to has a bible for kids shoved into their hands at age 5. Its disgusting brainwashing for a cult. This is why we have education issues in the US.
Wtf kind of family gatherings are these?
White people gonna try to colonize no matter what I guess
Patriarchy is good when others do it.
Never said it was good
Assuming conservatism is an inherent part of “the foreigners” is what I find wrong with this post, but your comment does the same assumption…
I never assumed conservatism. It’s, that to me the post reeks of western chauvinism since i read it as that this white woman seems to be excited to tell the kids of her, presumably new, non white family, their family structure and religion are wrong. Maybe the family is conservative, maybe not, either way I don’t think white people should be looking forward to telling non white folks that their traditions are wrong, unless they want to sound like a colonial trope.
Toll payment incoming.
Why’s everyone putting the wife on blast? It’s not colonization to be critical of religion.
The worst kind of religious people are the ones who are completely convinced that they’re not religious.
The worst kind of religious people are the ones using it as a justification for genocide, but I’ll give yours a spot on the podium.
This is a woman who chooses not to confirm to her extended families religiously conservative viewpoints, and sees positive feedback from the kids. Not exactly a coloniser.
It’s one thing to challenge religion and conservative beliefs.
It’s quite another thing to frame herself as an enlightened outsider bringing progressive values to a supposedly backward family.
Especially when this post makes it a point to her as as young, Swedish, and progressive, in contrast to her husband’s Indonesian family—which is supposedly not.
It’s further suspicious when she treats children as instruments of ideological conflict. If it’s merely a matter of teaching young people to think critically—okay. But if this is just an exercise in trying to get children to adopt your particular conclusions, she’s teaching them nothing except another prescriptive moral stance.
Finally, she prides herself on making others question their assumptions. But how willing is she to question her own? If she’s just administering criticism without doing her own self-examination, then I question whether she’s applying this principle universally.
Finally, posting this on social media is quite performative. The post is structured around the satisfaction she derives from being a disruptive presence at family gatherings. The children, religion, and patriarchy are supporting characters in a story about her own self-image.
For this reason, I don’t think she’s quite deserving of a high-five.
Assuming it was posted in good faith, this woman’s post was probably not meant to be a condemnation of Indonesian culture.
It sounds to me that this woman is probably just happy to share progressive ideas that she inherited from her cultural background and sees as good with kids who maybe aren’t exposed to those particular aspects. I think any man or woman who marries into another culture takes a little pleasure in bringing their own flavor into their new family just as much as they enjoy taking in those new flavors. Especially when the thing that they’re introducing is something like, I don’t know, feminism.
Cultural exchange goes both ways. It would be absurd for her to post this one happy and slightly strange aspect of her life and then post a paragraph or two explaining how it doesn’t reflect any pro-colonial or racist ideas. It would be strange to coach your post on social media like that. I don’t know why you would expect that.
You offer such an extraordinary amount of charitable good faith to OP that it verges on gaslighting.
But I will extend extra good faith of my own by pointing out you are defending the woman’s good intentions while I’m pointing out that—regardless of her intentions—her post is troublesome all the same.
She might be genuinely well-intentioned, sincerely feminist, and interested in helping children think critically. Fine.
None of that establishes that her framing is free of Eurocentric assumptions. You don’t have to consciously endorse racial or cultural hierarchies to reproduce them.
You’ve also inadvertently reinforced my central argument: you describe feminism as progressive ideas the woman “inherited from her cultural background.”
But feminism isn’t uniquely Swedish or European. And actually, Indonesia has its own substantial feminist history.
Treating progressive values as something Europeans bring to non-European societies Is white supremacist as hell.
And your appeal to cultural exchange doesn’t address the asymmetry. Sure, cultural exchange goes both ways. That’s true, but OP isn’t describing a reciprocal exchange.
Instead, she’s celebrating her status as a Swedish woman introducing her progressive worldview to an Indonesian family. Nothing in the post suggests she’s similarly interested in questioning her own cultural assumptions.
Finally, you’re attacking an expectation I didn’t express. Nobody demanded that the woman write paragraphs disavowing colonialism or racism.
My criticism is about what she chose to emphasize, specifically her Swedish identity and supposedly progressive values against her husband’s Indonesian family.
I’m pretty sure I love you.
Man, some people deriving a lot of assumptions from a couple non-descript lines.
How come this can’t be written off as their mere presence/appearance, body language, and mannerisms causing questions without them proselytizing their views?
Sometimes that’s more than enough before words are even spoken. Kids are observant.
I think everyone has that exhausting relative that starts talking politics to the kids