Should the primarily Palestinian Israeli parties join the Eisenkot coalition?
#EvanPoll #poll #israel #knesset #PalestiniansOf1948 #IsraelElection #Palestine
Should the primarily Palestinian Israeli parties join the Eisenkot coalition?
#EvanPoll #poll #israel #knesset #PalestiniansOf1948 #IsraelElection #Palestine
@evan yes, but with preconditions such as getting netanyahu out of power and respecting the human rights of Palestinians.
@jamesmarshall
> yes, but with preconditions such as getting netanyahu out of power
The only way to get Netanyahoo out of power is for Eisenkot to get a majority, and the Arab-Israeli partied have already committed to backing his bloc for that reason. The only remaining question is whether Netanyahoo can block the transfer of power to keep himself out of prison. This seems like a good overview, from a veteran kiwi journalist;
(1/2)
@strypey @jamesmarshall they only committed to supporting him as the person who gets to try to form a new government first. They didn't commit to support him inside or outside the coalition.
@strypey @jamesmarshall Eisenkot is also not committed to the Arab parties -- far from it. He is negotiating with Likud to form a "national unity" government so they don't have to include the ethnic minority parties, which is kind of a bullshit definition of "national unity". He's also trying to peel off parts of the Netanyahu coalition without losing parties on his own side.
@strypey @jamesmarshall it's a comforting fiction that liberals and leftists are partnering with an ethnic minority to end an authoritarian warmongering regime. Most of the parties on Eisenkot's side oppose a two-state solution; the Democrats want an autonomous Palestine under military occupation "some day". Some of the parties advocate for expulsion of Palestinian Israeli citizens. They all dogpiled Balad leader Sami Abu Shehadeh so he would be disqualified from running for the Knesset.
There's a good discussion of the issues here:
@evan Given all of that, I don't really understand the purpose of the poll question.
@strypey @jamesmarshall the purpose is to see whether people think the parties should join the coalition.
@evan well sure, but by what precise definition of "join the coalition"? I interpreted the question as asking whether they should back Eisenknot to form a government, but you clearly had something quite different in mind. Exactly what, I'm still not clear on.
I am not a parliamentary democracy expert, but my understanding of a party participating in a coalition government is that the party votes with the government, its leader and maybe other members are ministers, the party participates in decision making, and it stands publicly behind government policies (even if it argues against them internally).
@strypey @jamesmarshall a party that supports the government from the outside may negotiate policy concessions from the government in exchange for its support, but it does not have cabinet ministers and is not consulted on government policy. The party is free to vote against the government, except for confidence votes. It can also speak against the government on other issues.
@strypey @jamesmarshall I think in New Zealand the best recent example is the Clark government, 2002 to 2005. Labor and the Progressives were in coalition and both had ministers. United Future was outside the government and provided support and supply.
@evan
Please help my family π
https://gaza-verified.org/people/@Hanadi95@mastodon.social/
@evan
Please help me buy food for my family. I am the only breadwinner and the only one taking care of them. We desperately need food. Please don't leave my family hungry. ππ΅πΈ
https://gaza-verified.org/people/@Hanadi95@mastodon.social/
Thanks to everyone who replied. I think if it's possible, they should stick close to the coalition. They have a real chance to be a check on the most aggressive government behaviour. Yes.
@evan
Every day is a struggle for survival. π Today, all we had to eat was lentils, and we haven't been able to secure food for tomorrow, Friday. My sick parents desperately need healthy, nutritious food. Eating lentils has caused them severe digestive problems and bloating. Please help me provide food for my family of five. I am the only one caring for and providing for them, and I don't know how we will get through another day.ππ΅πΈ
https://gaza-verified.org/people/@Hanadi95@mastodon.social/
These would be Ra'am and the parties that make up the Joint List.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ra%27am
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_List
Joint List
Ra'am