Always "fun" to get responses to what you've written saying that your assumptions in an essay are wrong, before listing the "assumptions" and they either don't appear in the essay or are things I specifically cited as not affecting the argument one way or another
Like, some of this stuff I literally covered in both the video and the essay!
Me: "if demand declines prices and wages will follow"
Them: "ah, but what if demand doesn't decline?! Gotcha!"
What do people think "if" means? "if this, then that" is a fucking conditional. How have you been able to code without understanding what a fucking conditional is?
@baldur As someone who used to teach discrete maths to people who had already passed five semesters of programming exams:
You'd *really* be surprised.
@baldur I've noticed a thing where people *have* to ask questions like that even though they don't make logical sense, just for the sake of questioning. Because I suppose you get extra marks at school for pointless questions or something, I don't know.
So far, I’ve gotten variations on both:
“Your argument falls apart because you assume agentic coding doesn’t work when it does”
And
“Your argument falls apart because you assume agentic coding does work when it doesn’t.”
@baldur My half-assed bad faith recreation of your argument falls apart immediately. Therefore you are wrong.
@baldur Maybe they only read an AI summary.
:(
@baldur Yes, many people don't understand the simple fact, that one can't disagree with a statement without first understanding it.
@baldur It's so frustrating. FWIW (and I know you know): You presented a very well-argued analysis. That of course people can disagree with but all relevant assumptions/branches were outlined super clearly.
@tante It's also not as if I want to be right about any of this. I would really enjoy seeing any of the underlying assumptions fall apart or get conclusively proven to be incorrect.
@baldur People are in so much of a hurry to show how smart they are by criticizing, that they don't bother reading what it is they're criticizing and make themselves look pretty unintelligent.