why does sony require formatting to go between pal and ntsc?
the grammar being wrong also bothers me
the grammar being wrong also bothers me
Sorry, but everything you wrote there is utter bullshit as is applicable to a modern and completely digital mirrorless camera.
Are you suggesting that digital cameras don’t run on electricity? Lol
No, I’m stating the incontrovertible fact that a digital and completely DC powered device does not have the frequency of its internal components “conditioned” by its connected power source, lol.
Among quite a few other things.
Just checked this camera manual (2015 Sony Alpha 7RII). It does H.264 (it calls it AVC, and it also uses specifically AVCHD, exclusive to Sony. So, old version) encoding of video. That encoding does have PAL and NTSC hard requirements when recording 24fps, 1080 24fps is only possible in progressive mode, which means it is tied to analog standards. The rolling shutter has to match the target frame rate. Encoding is done on the memory card, it is called real time compression. It is a format intended to create DVD and Blu-Ray direct compatibility files. Which were still, back then, held back by PAL and NTSC standards as they were targeting a TV market that were still technically very analog limited¹.
The camera also has TV out (early microHDMI it seems), which is also limited by PAL/NTSC compatibility of the TV.
Like, this camera won’t do 24fps video in PAL mode, for example. It also won’t do MP4 for more than 20 minutes because it has a file size limit of 4GB. That is the age of technology we are dealing with. Things are not magical just because they are digital. There are hard technical limits and there’s a history behind the development of technology we have today. This camera cannot record certain fps settings when an HDMI monitor is connected at the same time, that tells me there’s hard wired video processing that lock steps a ton of what the camera can and cannot do.
¹: quick note, TVs are actually still limited by NTSC/PAL standards. Manufacturers have just implemented several tricks to circumvent technical limitations. Such as TVs nowadays can detect which type of grid they are connected to and pick and choose workarounds depending on what the user is trying to play. This usually creates certain artifacts, like when a 50hz TV is trying to play a 24fps or 60fps digital video, for example. For the vast majority of content you wouldn’t notice unless you were looking for it. But on some movies it is extremely obvious, since it changes the pace of movement by dropping or repeating frames in a way that was not intended by the file format.
You are just making completely wild guesses here.
Seriously you sound like a LLM stuck in a hallucination.
I was originally going to make a pithy comment here about how televisions never derived their sync frequency from the mains because I know full well that the sync pulse for analog television is sent along with the video signal from the transmitter and the TV is slaved to it. In the absence of this TVs from my era had their own oscillators that generated the appropriate sync frequency which may or may not have been in phase with the frequency of whatever it was they were trying to receive, and thus also a sync splitter circuit that attempted to switch the start of frame to be in lockstep with either the sync pulse from the station if it was strong enough and the internal timing when it wasn’t. The whole point of this was to be able to display at least some manner of intelligible image to the user as an aid to getting the station tuned in.
But then I remembered a key phrase there, which was televisions from my era.
(This is all just whiffling and is completely irrelevant to photography, so everyone who isn’t specifically interested in this rather off-topic diatribe is encouraged to ignore it.)
I had apparently blocked out the memory that prewar television sets in fact did derive their frequency from the mains. As it happened this turned out to be exactly as stupid of an idea as you think it was. Foremost isn’t actually the obvious consideration that the mains frequency isn’t all that accurate to begin with, but rather it’s the fact that it is spectacularly unlikely to be in phase with the frequency of whatever transmitting tower your TV is listening to. One which would of course be any arbitrary distance away, and not even guaranteed to be on the same grid. These interactions resulted in the appearance of “hum bar” artifacts on your screen where the refresh cycles didn’t quite line up. Sometimes these could be tidied away into an inconspicuous or even off-screen area with careful tuning (compensating for this sort of thing is part of what the old vertical and, ye gods forbid if we’re going back that far, horizontal hold knobs on old television sets were for), but if you were particularly unlucky due to wandering frequency timings they’d be rolling up and down your screen constantly.
Obviously the entire industry was keen to do away with this nightmare as soon as it was technologically feasible, and when transistors came about they sure did.
Once NTSC color came along they didn’t have a choice anyway, because the cycle frequency of color television isn’t 60hz like the mains anymore. In order to leave room — or rather time — for the colorburst signal, the frequency of not-actually-modern-anymore NTSC television is actually 59.94hz. So if you’ve ever wondered where that weird frame rate still available in all your video editing software comes from, now you know.
Please explain, I’m interested in the technical details.
What this commenter wrote almost makes sense if this camera were an oldschool analog device, think the era of tape camcorders and VCRs and so forth. And tube televisions and even the retro game consoles connected to them, for that matter. These machines were all heavily tied to the frequency and timings of their native video signal format, either NTSC or PAL (or even SECAM, if you want to get really obscure).
This is absolutely not the case with a modern flagship mirrorless camera. The Sony ɑ7RII in OP’s picture is a flagship high end camera. It is obviously not only eminently capable of altering its shutter rate, sensor refresh speed, and video recording frame rate to any arbitrary value but is purpose built to be able to do so. The only part of its componentry at all that is operating at NTSC/PAL frequencies at any point is whatever tiny amount of DAC hardware it’s using to output that low-def TV signal (probably composite video) out the little barrel jack on the side, and even then only when you’ve got it plugged into an analog TV.
Analog NTSC and PAL are very different from each other. Digital “NTSC” and “PAL” (in reality there’s really no such thing) are not. The block of NTSC countries have TV’s that expect a 60hz frame rate and those in traditionally PAL countries expect a 50hz frame rate. That’s literally it.
The following claims are bogus:
You can fake the video with just the framerate
No, that’s literally what digital HD video does nowadays, like the type you’d transmit over an HDMI cable.
implies the entire electric circuit ran at a specific frequency
This was true for analog devices and those whose timings had to be tied to the output frequency, but is not the case for a digital device that handles all of its signal processing internally.
Which is easier to do if everything inside the camera, shutter, pixel refresh, encoding, etc. runs on the same frequency.
This is not even remotely what a high end modern camera does. Sony is obviously mum about the exact specifications of the “Bionz X” main image processor in the ɑ7RII, but it is obviously a modern highly specialized chip running most likely running at many hundreds of megahertz, completely independent of the camera’s external video output.
If the camera can be fed with direct power it will also condition the internal components frequency.
I think this grammatically malformed statement is trying to imply that the camera must run in lockstep with its input power frequency. If so, this could only be true if the camera were an analog running directly off of mains current from a wall outlet. This is not so for any digital camera; they’re DC devices primarily fed from their battery which obviously has no electricity frequency and if they’re externally powered this is also through DC from an ADC to DC step down converter. No part of the mains voltage frequency should be making it to the camera. If it did, this would be very bad. Smoke would certainly be involved.
Furthermore, the mains voltage frequency is not nearly accurate or consistent enough to tie the operating frequency of any electronic device to it. You can easily observe this with oldschool analog clocks which derive their drive speed directly from the 50 or 60hz frequency of their mains power supply; they don’t keep very good time. So electronic devices even if they ostensibly “run at” their countries’ analog TV frequency at 60 or 59.94 or 50hz or whatever still use their own internal crystal oscillators to create that frequency accurately rather than blithely relying on the mains frequency.
If it is for sync when recording screens or using old lights, the entire camera must run on the same frequency, or the skip when faking framerates is actually still noticeable.
Once again it is trivially verifiable that this is not so; I have point and shoot cameras from the early 2000s which can change both their flash sync and screen sync settings on the fly with no ill effect, no reboot or reformat required, and the results are clearly visible. Anybody with a camera in their hands could verify this in about four seconds without having to resort to spouting any bullshit.
All this would require restarting the electronics to run on the correct frequency.
No, it just requires setting the recording framerate to the correct value and optionally tuning to start the frame exposure at the correct time. Which again, any competent digital camera can already do.
All this would require restarting the electronics to run on the correct frequency.
Again again, again. For the umpteenth time, the camera’s internal hardware is processing at its own internal clock speed completely independent of its video outputs.
The old encodes go beyond just containers, they do bitwise manipulation as well. Electrical system agnosticism is a modern result of newer container formats.
This is either willfully or ignorantly conflating the way that analog and digital video encoding work, with a sprinkling of buzzwords thrown in food good measure.
I will have to agree with this comment about BS.
The camera can make its own clock internally to shoot whatever frame rate it needs. Otherwise you’d be stuck at multiple of 50 or 60 Hertz for all images. You can basically arbitrarily pick a shutter speed for photos. Including 1/60 or 1/50 or 1/48 of a second. Yes I know NTSC is not 1/60, but B&W pre NTSC video was indeed 1/60 of a second sync.
Considering there are thousands of other models of cameras that let you pick PAL or NTSC without formatting, the other comment is just nonsense.
There is really no need for formatting for going from PAL to NTSC besides maybe some legal thing about how the camera is classified. Long ago there was time limits on a stills camera video recording in certain countries, not a size limit.
And that last part is really the kicker. If Sony needs to reboot the thing to get the processors running in sync or whatever it takes that’s their own prerogative. Maybe there’s a technical limitation there; I didn’t engineer the damn thing, whatever. But none of that explains why a memory card reformat should even be remotely necessary.
I waited a bit to put a top level reply on this because I wanted to go home and mess with my selection of cameras to ensure I wasn’t grossly misremembering something and I didn’t have any of them on me at work. For shame, for shame, I know.
Here is the headline that matters: I, unlike many of the commenters here, am going to freely admit that any speculating I do here is me completely talking out of my ass. The truth of it is that we will never know the actual answer for this quirk except in the unlikely event that a Sony engineer happens to pass by our humble community or possibly if somebody manages to corner one of them and nail him down to an answer somehow.
My take on the matter is that the forced card reformat smells like an artificial limitation and is either likely due to some combination of Sony flavored ineptitude and/or apathy, or is equally likely to be a deliberate and completely on brand customer hostile action on their part in true Sony tradition. Most likely as some manner of limp-dicked attempt at content region locking.
You know, coming from the guys who are infamous for being instrumental in insisting that region locking must be written right into the DVD specification, among other things, over and above the inherent NTSC/PAL/SECAM incompatibilities already inherent in all of those flavors of gear.
I would 100% believe that the camera is not capable of outputting NTSC video when it’s in PAL mode and vise versa for some manner of obscure technical or software limitation. Locking out the video frame rates that are incompatible with your region likewise makes sense, even if only to not give the user enough rope to hang himself. And with the best will in the world, unless the user is deliberately hooking their camera up to some manner of multisync display device it’s not going to work if you plug it into something from the wrong region anyway, especially if you’re doing it over composite.
But the formatting your memory card thing feels like one of those extra special Sony flavored fuck-yous, right up there with rootkits on their music CDs, MagicGate… hell, even SonicStage, and all the rest of it.
So for the record this is a Canon household. I do not have a kind spot anywhere in my heart for Sony and for myriad reasons I never will.
However.
My ancient Powershot SX130 IS: Allows me to freely switch between NTSC and PAL, right there in the menu. When I exit the menu, it is already active. No reboot required, no reformat required.
My R10: Again allows me to switch between NTSC and PAL, right there in the menu. No reboot, no reformat. This camera can output externally solely in HDMI, for whatever it’s worth.
My EOS 40D: Wouldn’t you know it, this also allows me to switch between NTSC and PAL. No reboot, no reformat. But the sole effect this has as far as I can tell is changing the flavor of the analog video output via the barrel jack on the side.
Just for grins sies I took a short video clip of the blinkenlights inside my computer tower with both my SX130 and my R10 in NTSC mode, then switched to PAL and checked if I could play it back. The answer is yes, no problem. (And the 40D actually doesn’t have a dedicated video mode, believe it or not, so we don’t get a third data point.) The R10 does change its offering of recording frame rates depending on whether you have it set to NTSC or PAL, but the SX130 is not that complicated and doesn’t allow you to change its inbuilt video framerate, resolution, or aspect ratio at all. But it still works either way.
So in the absence of a first hand source, we can describe it thusly: Incompetence, indifference, or malice. Pick any three.
I’m not sure about the camera itself. But PAL and NTSC go beyond just a framerate. You can fake the video with just the framerate but it actually implies the entire electric circuit ran at a specific frequency. Which is easier to do if everything inside the camera, shutter, pixel refresh, encoding, etc. runs on the same frequency. If the camera can be fed with direct power it will also condition the internal components frequency.